DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed.

Posted by: synergy

DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 11:13

Well... I've been through all of the lists for Mercedes. The adapter I was hoping for, doesn't seem to exist. So, my options have dropped to a few....

1> Rip the whole damn MB sound system out, replace with my own aftermarket stuff, including the Empeg.
Pro:
a> Probably the best sound.
b> Empeg is back in control.
Cons:
a> Lose the warranty, since a hell of a lot of the computer goes through the same pathways.
b> Lose the steering wheel controls, which also control a fair amount of the car's functionality.
c> It's going to cost a shitload of money.

2> Find a FM transmitter of decent quality that takes 12V DC and RCA ins. Mount Empeg below radio in the dash, and have a preset.

Pro:
a> shouldn't cost very much past the installation charge (custom making an mounting adapter for the empeg.)
b> integrates ok with the MB stuff, and I don't lose the controls.
c> Easy to pull should I sell the car.

Con:
a> Isn't going to sound any better than the FM radio. (which is pretty good, but...)


1 isn't going to happen. As much as I'd love to rip the stereo out and drop my own stuff in, I can't lose the functionality, and don't really want to get into the job of pulling all of the equipment out and reinstalling stock when I sell the car.

2 seems to be a pretty good compromise, IF I can find a decent transmitter. Therefore... Anyone have any recommendations?
Posted by: philp69

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 11:31

Crutchfield has exactly what you need... You can also get one at your local stereo shop. It connects in series with your antenna and will modulate the audio to an unused FM channel. Just make sure you get one with the correct antenna connectors.
Posted by: n2toh

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 13:36

A company in the US has a kit for a digital tuned FM stereo transmiter. the company can be found here. http://www.ramseyelectronics.com/cgi-bin/commerce.exe?preadd=action&key=FM25

I also would like to construct a box to use my player in other cars.

check www.riocar.org I would like to controll the transmit frequency thru the empeg.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 14:11



Crutchfield has exactly what you need... You can also get one at your local stereo shop. It connects in series with your antenna and will modulate the audio to an unused FM channel. Just make sure you get one with the correct antenna connectors.



That is EXACTLY what I need. I looked at Crutchfield, but didn't find it the first time... Looking in the wrong area I guess. Thanks for the link.

I'm hoping the SQ is ok... I've been in my new baby (C230K) for a couple of weeks, and love it, but I'm missing my old baby(empeg) and having to deal with a 6 disc changer only....

I can hardly wait to get it installed again... And will HAVE to get an aluminium fascia for it to match the aluminium trim....
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 14:17

Have you gone to a merc dealer and tryed to find someone that is switched on and technical.

Option 3 if a cd changer is avalable it might have an audio output/input from the cd changer which you might be able to splice into

option 4 there will be an amp of some sort somewhere maybe which you could feed into as that is what some folk have done with and sound system in the audi TT

Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 14:17

Perhaps you can find adapter which transforms your factory head unit's CD changer inputs into AUX-in? That way you would probably get much better sound than via FM.
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 14:23

option 5 pull the plugs off the back of the mb speakers, mount an amp in the boot/somewhere, run from amp to speakers as normal fit the empeg under the dash as transmitter plan and run RCAs to amp.
When time comes to sell car whatever return plugs remove empeg and you be back to norm.

You can also get modules that take a high level output from speakers and drop it down to a low level input for an amp so you could take a feed from one of the speakers into this and then into empeg aux and you have anything that is piped to them from mb system such as sat nav commands.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 14:31


Perhaps you can find adapter which transforms your factory head unit's CD changer inputs into AUX-in? That way you would probably get much better sound than via FM.



Been there, done that.

That was my first try. MB uses a Fiber-optic connection between EVERYTHING. The Changer has a dual fiber input to it. It's actually pretty cool, but there isn't an aftermarket add-in for it yet (and probably not for at least a year, based on my conversations).

I HAD one of those (actually I still do) for Alpine that I hoped would work, but recently they moved the whole control system over to Fiber. It's still Alpine, but it's a F*cked up protocol from what I can tell. The Radio and changer have to be programmed see each other on the bus... They will work at first when you do the installation, but after about a week or two, enough errors will be generated, that the MB computer shuts the changer down. Then, go to MB, let them hook up a laptop to the system, and program it. It will work without a problem then.

It's sort of cool having a car this intelligent, but I've heard horror stories about getting the system to accept aftermarket parts. If the part doesn't generate exactly the same current draw or signals, it shuts it down. Try replacing the headlights with Hids? (55w normal H7 bulbs, with 35W HID system... ) The computer sees less of a draw, assumes something is wrong, and shuts them down to prevent damage. Tell it you have Hids installed, and click, everything works well.
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 14:43

Ugh! Perhaps you should really go the FM route, then...

Of course, it did not appear to designers of this marvel to provide AUX input....
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 15:42

i like having a dum car where they still use wires
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:20



Ugh! Perhaps you should really go the FM route, then...

Of course, it did not appear to designers of this marvel to provide AUX input....



Well... Truth be told.... The Comand system (MB's Nav gear, with lcd and all) does apparently have an aux in capability. It's not advertised, and it's not easy to get to, but it is possible.

The problem is : a> I don't have it, on this car. b> it's really sorta a piece of junk, and c> I can't put it in this car without about $5K of modifications, plus the MB tech time.

The other problem is that with it installed, there is no space available for the empeg...

FM it is. The good news is that the tuner in the MB is really pretty good. That Clarion module looks to be pretty good, so I'm hoping there isn't going to be a huge drop in quality. I mean MOST of the degradation of FM is from the Station compressing the [censored] out of the music, and dropping freq, so it sounds good on ALL cars, right? Plus of course, the signal levels are going to vary, and wave patterns are going to be affected by the terrain...

That SHOULDN'T happen in this kit.... I'm guessing I'll see a bit of a reduction in the dynamic range, due to bandwidth capabilities, but otherwise, it should be a clean signal. Unfortunately, I have no experience in the FM changer field...I always went for the headunit controlled variety before.
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:21

Your suggestion of wiring an amp to the speakers would still work. There's no way they're running optical to the speakers. :)

The empeg should be able to be hooked up as a preamp for the MB radio, using its speaker outputs (even if you have to fish them from elsewhere in the car with additional wiring) using a line-level converter.

Bruno
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:26


i like having a dum car where they still use wires


he he he.

I was actually pretty shocked when I found out that the throttle linkup is fly by wire.... It's not a direct connection. The gas pedal feeds an actuator, that the computer works off of. Then, dependant on the throttle position, it opens the gas, adjusts the fuel map, etc. Plus, it also looks at the rate of change on the throttle position, and adjusts the transmission responsiveness. Slowly apply the gas... it acts one way... Punch the pedal, and the transmission jumps about 4 gears.

It's cool.

Downside.... MB in the USA doesn't even have the OPTION of an indash CD player. Tape only. You want CD's, buy the $900 changer.

I wouldn't guess that one of Empeg's OEM customers was MB.....
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:29

in dash tape use the empeg travel kit method as small tape adaptor for using a personnel cd player with a in dash tape player quick and dirty but it will get you running
Posted by: jarredduq

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 26/12/2001 16:30

In reply to:

A company in the US has a kit for a digital tuned FM stereo transmiter. the company can be found here. http://www.ramseyelectronics.com/cgi-bin/commerce.exe?preadd=action&key=FM25

I also would like to construct a box to use my player in other car.




I purchased an FM25b from Ramsey so I could hook my Empeg up to it. Now I can listen to my Empeg all over the house! It took approximately 5 hours to assemble and has excellent sound quality.

In the past before I had my Empeg, I purchased that RF modulator from Crutchfield for my NEO and was disatisfied with the sound. It really gave the music a "muffled sound," so I ended up buying a new head unit with an Aux input.

A couple of weeks ago I had a rental car, while my car was being painted and missed my Empeg badly. So I hooked up the Empeg and FM25b to the cigeratte lighter. The sound quality was quite good, as it is in my house.

You'll find many uses for the FM25b. I also take it with me when I DJ, so I can setup a couple of radios in areas where people can't hear the music. This prevents me from blasting the people who are sitting close to my main speakers during dinner.
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:34

Have you talked to the people at www.peripheral-aamp.com ? They do make CD-changer products for a number of Mercedes vehicles.

You should also seek the help of Mercedes themselves. They should have parts to facilitate addition of new non-Mercedes gear.

This would be reason enough for me to not buy a vehicle. And it's something I'll make sure to ask of any dealer in the future.

Bruno
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:34


Your suggestion of wiring an amp to the speakers would still work. There's no way they're running optical to the speakers. :)

The empeg should be able to be hooked up as a preamp for the MB radio, using its speaker outputs (even if you have to fish them from elsewhere in the car with additional wiring) using a line-level converter.



That's true, and it certainly could be done. Choosing the correct set of leads might be fun, as there is 7 speaks, including the center channel. There is some digital processing done on it for driver's position and crap like that. Plus, I don't want to get into putting an amp and new system into this car though. It's not going to be nearly as easy to do as the old GS-R. And unfortunately, I'm getting lazy in my old (29 years) age.

More to the point, I'm looking for something that can pull quickly and easily if I move cars again. Getting the GS-R gear pulled and replaced was a b*tch, and it wasn't nearly as involved as this would be.

I just GOT TO get back to the Empeg... It's sitting on my desk at work... Watching the timeplot is just TOO cool... I NEED this in the MB...
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:35


in dash tape use the empeg travel kit method as small tape adaptor for using a personnel cd player with a in dash tape player quick and dirty but it will get you running


Won't work.... the tape retracts into the dash, and closes a door behind it... Which doesn't close with the wire, and the thing stops and beeps at you. Alot.

Tried that the first night.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:43


Have you talked to the people at www.peripheral-aamp.com ? They do make CD-changer products for a number of Mercedes vehicles.

You should also seek the help of Mercedes themselves. They should have parts to facilitate addition of new non-Mercedes gear.

This would be reason enough for me to not buy a vehicle. And it's something I'll make sure to ask of any dealer in the future.


Yup. They were the first guy's I DID talk to. They don't have anything for the new systems yet. From talking to them, they ARE working on it, but it's looking like it will be a while.

Mercedes (the local dealer) is being very helpful about it... much better than I expected. However, Mercedes (MBUSA) is not. They have the lock in, and are using it. Their incar phone system uses Motorola phones that have been modded with a chip to make them the only phones capable of being used in the car. It's a $800 premium to get that chip. (standard phone runs about $400, the MB phone is @$1200). Mercedes (Worldwide) does not have this limitation. Of course, worldwide, they use GSM phones...

More and more systems are coming like this, I'm afraid. It's one of the reasons Empeg went to the OEM market from what I understand.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 26/12/2001 16:45


In the past before I had my Empeg, I purchased that RF modulator from Crutchfield for my NEO and was disatisfied with the sound. It really gave the music a "muffled sound," so I ended up buying a new head unit with an Aux input.


The Clarion was bad? but the FM25B sounded better, even without a direct antenna connection?
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 02:19

Well, keep us informed on progress. If the solution turns out to be satisfactory, it might save some other empegger blood, sweat and tears. :)
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 04:19

The more i read this the more i like my ten year old BMW with nice little things like throttle cable and i don't even want to think about how fly by wire brakes work when the fuse blows.

To be entirly honest i would not buy a car that complicated.

i once had a audi and the relay for the fuel pump blew so to get home under the rear seat the cable for the rear fogs passed by the cable for the fuel pump so i spliced the two together and drove around like that for a week.

Another old car the clutch cable broke so i had to drive about 100miles clutchless

Also i ran an old van and the altenator died being poor i could not afford to get a new one so i got too old fishing boat batterys that i could lay my hands on and drove around with them in the boot and charged them up every couple of days

Try that with fibre optics it won't work.
Posted by: jarredduq

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 07:41

In reply to:

The Clarion was bad? but the FM25B sounded better, even without a direct antenna connection?




Yes. The problem I feel is that they have a brick wall filter that has too steep a slope and it's cutting out some of the high frequency information.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 07:41


If the solution turns out to be satisfactory, it might save some other empegger blood, sweat and tears. :)


Especially the tears. :)

I'm going to go talk to a local installer that does most of the custom work for the the country (ick) stars around here (Nashville). We'll see what he can do.

Should know something next week.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 07:49


my ten year old BMW with nice little things like throttle cable and i don't even want to think about how fly by wire brakes work when the fuse blows.


Given the tolerances on this car, plus it's unwillingness to work with anything OUT of spec, I'm not worried too much about the above problem. Without a doubt, this car is complicated. Without a doubt, you have to have a CS major to be fully competent in repairing this car.

Ok.

I don't expect to have the problems you are referring to, simply because the computer IS monitoring everything. When a component starts to go out, It's going to let you know, and you get it fixed. It's not a car that you are going to be able to kludge back together, and that's ok. Hell, you go into the reserve on the gas tank, and this car practically screams at you. You have an alternating display going from the range left on the tank to Visit a fuel center SOON! on the display.

I'd much rather deal with a car that is more solid state than mechanical. Less to break.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 07:52


The problem I feel is that they have a brick wall filter that has too steep a slope and it's cutting out some of the high frequency information.


Ugh. I was really hoping that it would work well. It's just the right size and matchup for me. Plus the fact that the FM25B is a kit for twice the money. The money part I'm not worried about, the soldering I am.

Hmmmm.
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 08:06

I supose but i am a very metal person as i be a marine engineer where it is metal good electronics bad. but that said the new generation of engines coming out everything is computer controled with exhaust vavles controled by a black box not a camshaft.

Posted by: tanstaafl.

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 27/12/2001 19:40

To be entirly honest i would not buy a car that complicated.

Ah, but you're falling into the trap that I hear so many grumpy old curmudgeons (like myself) complain of: "These new cars are so complicated you can't fix them yourself anymore. What a bogus deal that is..."

I'm here to tell you -- I've been both places: simple old cars you can fix yourself; and complicated new cars you can't fix yourself. And new cars are better!

Most of you are too young to remember the bad old days... when you traded a car in at 40,000 miles not because you wanted the status and new-car smell of a new car, but because at 40K your old car was worn out.

Remember every 3,000 miles doing a tuneup? "Points-Plugs-and-Condenser" was considered to be one word.

How about a 1-year, 12,000 mile warranty?

Drum brakes were nice -- you could change the brake shoes yourself -- and as long as you didn't want make more than two high-speed stops in the same 5 minute period, or stay in a straight line while you applied them, they worked just fine.

Somebody who got 100,000 miles out of his engine was an object of awe and admiration. You'd do an upper-end overhaul (valves and piston rings) at about 50,000 miles.

Given the choice, I'd much rather have a car that I can't fix myself that rarely needs fixing and goes 10,000 miles between scheduled maintenance stops instead of some ineptly engineered vehicle designed and built so crudely that even I could work on it.

Modern cars, in no small part because of their electronic complexity, far outperform their predecessors in every aspect: acceleration, braking, cornering, reliability, cost of operation, comfort, you name it. And amazingly enough, they cost less now than they did 30 years ago. (That's cost in real terms: how many hours do you have to work to purchase the car.)

So, yes, I'll happily take my overly complex computer-run, long-lived, high-performing car. You couldn't pay me to go back to the cars of 30 years ago. But, as I said, I'm a grumpy old curmudgeon. YMMV.

tanstaafl.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 00:15

Word.

In reply to:


that rarely needs fixing and goes 10,000 miles between scheduled maintenance stops




Oh! I don't even have those!!!! I've got a flexible Service system! Currently (after 2k miles... Suckers are pilling on quick, thanks to the holidays) I've got 9700 miles before I'm supposed to take it in. The car itself is still breaking itself in.... The computer is limiting the performance and beefing up the fuel map to break it in better than a human ever could. At 6k miles, the car is done, and you get a nice performance boost plus better gas mileage.

But the FSS is very cool. Run it hard, and you can watch the service interval get shorter... Take it easy on a long trip and it goes back up. It's got a maximum service interval of 20k miles.

As you said... the computers have their advantages...
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 01:11

i agree completely about modern cars are far better than older ones

what does worry me is the fact that it is getting to the point where you have to take your car to a main dealer as they are the only ones that have the software to service your car. I would object to paying over 50pound an hour for the serices of someone that is paid 7pound an hour.

If there was an open standard great i would be all for it but there ain't

I won't even start on my thoughts about kwik fit though
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 05:35

I wrote something along these lines yesterday, and then #$!@ IE crash ate it . Serve me right for not resurrecting or replacing my Linux laptop!

Anyway, you did not expect this old-timer to manage to refrain from adding some of his own stories, did you ?

I used to drive a long succesion of Citroën 2CVs, typically around 15 years old, bought for $100 or so. They were the most recent models, with a whooping 600ccm, 30HP 2-cylinder horizontally opposed air-cooled engines, and I once managed to attain the speed of 80mph (highway, downhill, favorable wind).

You never started a trip in one of these without few wrenches, screwdrivers and pliers, duct tape and some wire (copper and steel). However, it was all it took to repair any breakdown. I was never left stranded (not for long, anyway ) by this car.

BTW, they are still immensely popular. Take a Google search to see numerous clubs' and owner's pages.
2CV

Another example of user-repairable car was my cousin's Fiat 600. We once managed to drive it few miles with one of carburetor nozzles replaced with a stick fashioned from a twig. You would not expect such a car to be popular as a racer, yould you? Well, see photos at the bottom of this page.

(BTW, for a hilarious example of babelfish translation see this Fiat 600 club site)

Well, I now drive Renault Twingo. For me it has the same feel as my old 2CVs, but technologically cannot be more different. When you start it, first you hear whining, buzzing, clicking and whirling of various motors and servos, then you watch dozen or so self-test lamps extinguishing... The only problem I had in its 35000 miles is that occasionally, if on wet day I pass very closely to a strong radio emiter so that it is on my righthand side, one computer or another picks unbelievable data on speed of one of the wheels and switches ABS off .



(These are not photograps of my cars - I don't have a digital camera - but stolen from two of numerous club sites; I am sure owners would not mind ...)

(Aren't we good at drifting off-topic, eh?)
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 11:11

can you think what our american friends would make of a 2cv
Posted by: tonyc

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 11:13

Haha le deux cheveaux or "two horses." I remember reading about those in French class.

Which would win in a race, a 2CV or a Trabant? Or would they both fall apart before the finish line?
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 11:23

you may joke but both cars are used for racing but i think you can get the trabby to go faster as it is a two stroke. There is even a 24hr endurance race for the 2cv
Posted by: tonyc

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 12:52

Hehehe wow. Endurance race... So the cars start out new and die within the 24 hour period? :)
Posted by: grgcombs

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 28/12/2001 13:17

For a second I thought you were wanting a REAL FM transmitter for your car. I've always wanted other people to be able to tune in to what I'm listening to.

Granted the FCC closes pirate stations down all the time, but I bet they wouldn't be expecting a mobile FM transmitter. Sure the range couldn't be too great, maybe only a few blocks, but it will still kick butt.

Greg
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 28/12/2001 13:31

[sigh] Remember the good old days when you could pretty much unilaterally broadcast low-powered FM? Now you have to get permission from the FCC, and you pretty much have to be an educational institution.
Posted by: synergy

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 14:05


For a second I thought you were wanting a REAL FM transmitter for your car. I've always wanted other people to be able to tune in to what I'm listening to.

Granted the FCC closes pirate stations down all the time, but I bet they wouldn't be expecting a mobile FM transmitter. Sure the range couldn't be too great, maybe only a few blocks, but it will still kick butt.


Well, the thought DID cross my mind. I had considered doing it in my Acura, but that thing has a motorcycle battery (almost)... I'd flatline it in a hurry. It would be pretty cool at the gym... Overpower the christian 'rock' station the Y is always tuned to with.... Rob Zombie or something similar.

Now I REALLY want to do it.
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 18:00

None of my 2CVs had less than 200000km on odometer (before odometer stoped functioning ). I was generally replacing the whole car because that was cheaper than replacing rusted-through parts of chasis (not shell; you could drive without shell, as I did once while is was being resprayed). Today, 20 years after manufacturing ceased, spare parts are still being produced (see, for example, here or here. The car was widely used in Algeria (actually, sometimes in fifties there was a desert rally version with two 425ccm engines (one in trunk), each powering two wheels (I am not saying one axle each because the thing had independent suspension all around from day one)). You can think of it as original Willis for civilian use - simple, practical, cheap, undestuctible.

Ah, I found the picture of 'spare engine' (the 'regular' one is in front - the thing is normally front wheels driven):



Trabi would probably be faster in races, because its 2 stroke engine can be tuned up more easily. However, its durability was greatly impeded by the fact that plastic used for doors, trunk lid etc. was considered delicious by hogs (I am not inventing this).

Speaking of races, have you seen those Fiat 600 Abarths photographs I linked to? They were extremely popular among rookie drivers 20 or so years ago. They were mean little machines, similar to those Brits made our of Minis.
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 18:02

I posted this so that they know 2CV was not invented for that James Bond movie
Posted by: tanstaafl.

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 20:11

whooping 600ccm, 30HP 2-cylinder horizontally opposed air-cooled engines,

Are you sure about that, Dragi? I seem to recall that the 2CV had considerably less power than that -- something in the neighborhood of 18 horsepower?

Regardless, the 2CV is a true milestone, one of the best cars ever made. I think it would not be improper to put the 2CV into the same exalted category as the Model T Ford, and the original Volkswagen. These were machines that quite literally changed the world, bringing incredibly reliable transportation to the masses at affordable prices.

I would not hesitate for an instant to start off on a cross-country trip of any duration over any terrain that any modern car could negotiate, in a 2CV. If the trip were grueling enough, almost certainly the 2CV would last longer than I would.

tanstaafl.
Posted by: tonyc

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 20:52

Well from the name, which translates to "two horses", I was under the impression that the original 2CV had 2 horsepower. Yes, two.

A quick net search confirms that my high school French teacher wasn't lying...

"The first 2CVs, designated 'A' series, had a 375cc engine and were rated at two horsepower on the French fiscal rating (hence its name 2CV or 'two horses')"

Obviously they've added more power since then, but I'm still not sure I'd trade in a good pair of blue jeans for a 2CV. :)
Posted by: tanstaafl.

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 28/12/2001 20:58

Obviously they've added more power since then, but I'm still not sure I'd trade in a good pair of blue jeans for a 2CV. :)

If you checked to see what used 2CVs sell for in this country (even ones in not great shape!) you'd jump at the chance to trade your entire wardrobe for one!



tanstaafl.
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 29/12/2001 03:54

Are you sure about that, Dragi? I seem to recall that the 2CV had considerably less power than that -- something in the neighborhood of 18 horsepower?

Oh, they started at 12HP and less than 400ccm, but all three I owned were late model ones with, IIRC, 21kW, which would translate to 28HP (this was the 602ccm engine that went into Diane and first models of Ami6

Regardless, the 2CV is a true milestone, one of the best cars ever made. I think it would not be improper to put the 2CV into the same exalted category as the Model T Ford, and the original Volkswagen. These were machines that quite literally changed the world, bringing incredibly reliable transportation to the masses at affordable prices.

Indeed. From the aspect of affordable transportation one could perhaps add small Fiats (at least here in Southern Europe), but not from the technological one. All three cars you mention were technological breakthroughs (especially Ford of course, then Citroën). Actually, Citroën was remarkably innovative company from thirties to sixties. Both Traction Avant (thirties, front wheel drive, automatic transmission) and DS (fifties, self-leveling hydro-pheumatic suspension, electronically controlled ignition, Cd=0.34) were at least a decade before their time, but managed to force their way to the market. (There was no shotrage of revolutionary cars that never saw mass production - e.g. Buckminster Fuller's Dymaxion)
Posted by: PeterH

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 07:00

Hmm as a 2CV and GS (yup, thats the model, not the trim level) owner for a number of years, I had always believed the the "two horses" cam from the original design spec given to Andre Citroen. he wanted to create a vehicle that would replace the standard farm buggy, which was pulled by two horses, the suspension was to be good enough that the farmer could (if neccesary) drive across a furrowed fieid without breaking a basket of eggs. A slightly different design spec than that used today, but it worked!
As a point of interest, i live in WesternAustralia, and we have a "road" called the gunbarrel highway. this streaches from a point about halfway up Western Australia and travels straight across to Alice Springs (The town that the famous Ayers Rock is near) it was last graded (leveled) in the late 60's and has been used by various adventurers to demonstrate their offroad ablities. Typically it is Kms of red dust and potholes, some as deep as 4 feet. About 8-10 years ago we had a "Raid" of 2cv and Citreon enthusiests from all over the world. we did the gunbarrel, and the only vehicle that got seriously bogged was the Nissan Patrol Support vehicle!
As another point of possible interest, the 2CV in the james bond movie was actually a "production" car. it was called a "Sidewinder" it was basically a 2CV body mounted on a GS chassis and motor. They used to go like a cut cat and supposedly could take a porche at the lights, perhaps the shock factor helped though. :-)
Posted by: PeterH

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 07:07

Hmm its not that difficult to "take over" the local radio reciever with a moderately powered transmitter. just build one that runs at 10.7 MHz or 21.4 MHz and the signal get straight into the IF stage of the reciever, even if they change the frequency of the tuner, it still comes through. i have done this a couple of times to suppress unwanted noise from neighbours who used to blast the radio all the time. I ran the input to my transmitter from the output of my stereo, so whatever i was listening to came out their radio. :-) and i didnt mind how loud they put it. They hardly ever thought to change over to CD input.
Posted by: TommyE

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 07:11

hahehahe. Naughty boy.

TommyE
Posted by: Nosferatu

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 07:58

As ca french empeg owner, and as a Citroen Xsara owner , I am very amazed to read threads about a french car like 'la deux chevaux'.

One of their innovative product on the 'DS' that was never produced was intelligent light on a car but I saw on TV that some european car brands are giving electronis ameliorations to the system :

It was 'only' turning lights adapted to the road.
Imagine you are driving in mountain with zig zag road and the next way of the road is turning to right , so the lights will turn to light the road and will give comfort to your driving because you don't discover to late the road.

This system should have been produced on a DS, but never made.


Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 14:26

Imagine you are driving in mountain with zig zag road and the next way of the road is turning to right , so the lights will turn to light the road and will give comfort to your driving because you don't discover to late the road.

This system should have been produced on a DS, but never made.


Oops, here I go breaking my promise not to discuss old cars in a general forum!

Citroën DS (most models of DS from 1967, as opposed to cheaper ID) did have road-following headlights. Take a look at this photo: inboard lights are high beams that follow the steering wheel. Here is a photo of a model without them (either ID or earlier model DS - I am not sure).

Another interesting relic from those glorious times, Citroën SM (M is for Maserati) - a coupe based on DS with Maserati engine - also had hydraulicaly operated road-following and self-leveling headlights (photo, details) - but not on the variant for American market. I also know this firsthand, because an acquaintance of mine has three SMs. (Interesting sidenote: several four-door variants of SM existed, including one convertible (SM Presidentielle) - of course, there were two-door convertibles, too.) For a good resource see, for example, here.
Searching the web for good photographs, I stumbled on several American shops specialising in Citroëns, one specifically in SM. I didn't see roadgoing 2CVs there, though .
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 14:35

And, FYI, the ill-fated Tucker had a single center-mounted road-following headlight in addition to the normal static two in 1947.

Edit: Changed 1957 to 1947. Oops.
Posted by: ClownBurner

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations needed. - 30/12/2001 15:02

Forgive my ignorance, but wouldn't the FM-10 do much the same job as the FM-25 at a lower price point? Granted, the range is probably more limited but for an in-car application I wouldn't think it would matter much, and it'd be 1/3rd the price...
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 15:30

"The first 2CVs, designated 'A' series, had a 375cc engine and were rated at two horsepower on the French fiscal rating (hence its name 2CV or 'two horses')"

375ccm engine actually had 12HP. As your qoute says, 2CV is fiscal rating (for taxation purposes) which has almost nothing to do with actual power (and CV is an acronym which, I think, means Catégoire Vehicules or something like that, certainly not Chevaux). Later model 2CVs had the same engine as Diane, but the later was rated 6CV. I don't know whether this scale is still used, but last time I heard about it 'normal' sedans were in 18CV or 20CV category. Of course, popular nickname 'Deux Chevaux' did want to stress that the thing did not have much more that 2HP.

...but I'm still not sure I'd trade in a good pair of blue jeans for a 2CV. :)

Well, I was not paying for mine much more.

Did you ever drive a dune buggy with very soft suspension? Well, the sensation is similar when you roll that canvas roof...
Posted by: bonzi

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 15:56

And, FYI, the ill-fated Tucker had a single center-mounted road-following headlight in addition to the normal static two in 1957.

No, I didn't know that (btw, you mean 1947, don't you?). Another car too good for the market... Why did it never advance past preproduction stage?
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: DC Powered FM Transmitter recommendations need - 30/12/2001 16:36

Oops, yeah -- 1947 (fixed). It didn't get into production because of financial and legal trouble. It was being independently produced and funded by pre-orders. The SEC didn't like some of the things they were doing (selling dealerships and accessories for a car that didn't exist, mostly) and brought them to court, where the company folded, despite being found innocent. There exists a conspiracy theory that the major American auto manufacturers somehow brought about the investigation and trial, but that's likely just a consipracy theory.