Cheap remote management console

Posted by: Roger

Cheap remote management console - 14/05/2013 16:05

Are there any cheap remote management consoles out there that: (a) work from bare metal? and (b) work over TCP/IP?

I ask because my Windows server is in a cupboard downstairs. When it goes wrong, I can usually remote desktop to it. When it goes severely wrong, I need to either rig a monitor to it (and there's not a lot of space), or I need to bring it upstairs to my study.

Are there any such devices as a VGA-to-VNC/RDP converter?
Posted by: canuckInOR

Re: Cheap remote management console - 14/05/2013 17:28

Here's the cheapest KVM over IP I could find. Otherwise, if you have a free PCI slot, you might try a RILOE (discontinued; <$20USD) or RILOE II board (~$100USD).

Posted by: Roger

Re: Cheap remote management console - 14/05/2013 19:20

Originally Posted By: canuckInOR
Here's the cheapest KVM over IP I could find.


That looks exactly like what I want, apart from the price smile. Thanks. Good to know that these things do exist, though.
Posted by: canuckInOR

Re: Cheap remote management console - 14/05/2013 21:43

Originally Posted By: Roger
Originally Posted By: canuckInOR
Here's the cheapest KVM over IP I could find.


That looks exactly like what I want, apart from the price smile.

Yeah, and that one's on sale at 50% off. :-p
Posted by: JBjorgen

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 00:08

Originally Posted By: Roger

I ask because my Windows server...When it goes severely wrong,


Alternatively, if you want to avoid this scenario, you could just run linux

*ducks and runs*
Posted by: Shonky

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 04:42

Those RILOE boards might be Compaq specific? All the brands have their own version don't they. Dell has DRAC etc. Aren't they usually a semi proprietary slot too and the server main board needs to actually support it? Lots of specifics.

They are awesome to use though. Proper power cycling, remote drives etc.
Posted by: drakino

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 14:52

Originally Posted By: Shonky
Those RILOE boards might be Compaq specific? All the brands have their own version don't they. Dell has DRAC etc. Aren't they usually a semi proprietary slot too and the server main board needs to actually support it? Lots of specifics.

It's been many years (and a profession change) but I'm pretty sure the RILOE and RILOE II that were linked to will work in any BIOS based computer just fine. It's not going to offer all the features, but they were just seen as standard video cards and some other devices to the system, along with using a normal PCI (not PCIe) slot.

http://webdevsys.com/lightsOut.htm has more info. Some people had success with remote power on as well, by hooking into the right cables inside their machine. About all you miss out on are Proliant specific features such as using the internal ribbon cable for Keyboard/Mouse instead of external PS/2 connectors. The boards were designed to go into Proliants prior to the 16/30 pin connector, hence the also broad non Compaq/HP support.

I wonder how many of the more advanced features work. For troubleshooting, the RILOE was awesome. It would video record any system crashes, allowing later replay. Windows bluescreen, Linux kernel panic, or a Netware abend, didn't matter.
Posted by: Roger

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 17:03

Originally Posted By: JBjorgen
Alternatively, if you want to avoid this scenario, you could just run linux


(ignoring the obvious troll smile ...) wouldn't necessarily help -- I'm looking for something that works from cold, and I've had just as many instances of Linux not booting up (or simply taking longer than expected) as I have of Windows.
Posted by: canuckInOR

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 20:34

Originally Posted By: Roger
Originally Posted By: JBjorgen
Alternatively, if you want to avoid this scenario, you could just run linux

(ignoring the obvious troll smile ...) wouldn't necessarily help -- I'm looking for something that works from cold, and I've had just as many instances of Linux not booting up (or simply taking longer than expected) as I have of Windows.

Maybe you need new hardware? Or more ventilation in your closet?
Posted by: Shonky

Re: Cheap remote management console - 15/05/2013 22:51

I was also going to suggest better hardware actually. All of these "addons" will probably not allow power cycles, hard resets etc. If those are your problems, I think you'd be better investing in something a bit more reliable.
Posted by: Roger

Re: Cheap remote management console - 16/05/2013 07:34

Originally Posted By: Shonky
I was also going to suggest better hardware actually. All of these "addons" will probably not allow power cycles, hard resets etc.


I don't care about those -- the PC's not remote -- it's just in a space where I can't easily add a monitor. I just want a way to see the "screen" remotely while the machine's booting up, so I can tell whether it's hung or merely taking a long time to boot up (e.g. installing updates or checking disks). Then I can decide whether to make a cup of tea or whether to go to the cupboard (on my way to the kitchen) and hard-reset it.

However, I can't easily run a VGA extension, for two reasons: (1) solid walls that have already been replastered recently, and (2) I'd rather not have an entire monitor on my desk for the computer downstairs.

Also, the space is relatively well-ventilated, so that's not the problem either.
Posted by: tahir

Re: Cheap remote management console - 16/05/2013 08:04

I used to have a KVM over IP thingy, I'll try and find it
Posted by: mlord

Re: Cheap remote management console - 16/05/2013 23:35

I would just set up the server for "serial console" and then run ordinary serial over existing(?) cat5. Much cheaper and possibly more reliable than a KVM-over-IP system.

Cheers
Posted by: Roger

Re: Cheap remote management console - 18/05/2013 15:27

Originally Posted By: mlord
I would just set up the server for "serial console" and then run ordinary serial over existing(?) cat5.


All of the CAT5 runs from that cupboard are already being used for Gig-E, and only one of them goes to the study. Also, the PC doesn't have any serial ports (and USB to serial ain't gonna work until it's part way through the boot process, which is kinda the problem).

Hey ho. I was merely wondering. If I could find a cheap VGA-frame-capture device, it might be a fun Raspberry Pi project (in my copious free time).
Posted by: Roger

Re: Cheap remote management console - 18/05/2013 15:33

Originally Posted By: tahir
I used to have a KVM over IP thingy, I'll try and find it


Thanks, but don't worry unduly -- it was partly idle speculation, rather than a pressing need.