Best Portable player right now?

Posted by: booey

Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 10:52

Im lookin for a new portable unit.
I still have a neo jukebox 2, although the batter life really sux, it still does its job and plays mp3s. which is all that i want it to do.
I really want to get a new unit, but all of them seem to have their own flaws. None seem to stand out.
IPOD's flaw is its price if you ask me. FM is a must for me now. I was also looking at this edigital odessy player http://www.edigital-store.com/odyssey1000.html , but have also heard some bad reviews.
any thoughts?

brian

Posted by: davekirk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 14:04

How much disk capacity is enough for you?
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 14:12

The Creative Zen looks really nice, and gets good reviews www.creative.com FM will be possible with the remote.

If you can wait 3-4 months, Rio will be bringing out the Pearl. Looks pretty nice, and developed by the Empeg guys so software etc should be flawless. I'm in the same boat as you - get an iPOD etc now, or wait for Pearl. I'm waiting for Pearl!!! Not sure about FM on this though.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 14:25

Although most of those reviews are probably by the same crowd that give every Creative product good reviews. I haven't played with one, so maybe I'm wrong, but I've pretty much given up on ever buying a Creative product again.

I'm waiting for the Pearl too.

Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 14:27

Yes, its very hard to get an independent and unbiased review these days. Maybe an Empegger has a Zen and can give a quick review. I think most have iPODs though.
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 14:48

Yeah, I agree. While that 60gig ZEN looks good, I'm also holding out for the Pearl. Rob promised it will be a real iPod killer.
Posted by: davekirk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 15:05

I have a Zen that I was planning to upgrade to 80GB, but with the current file count limitations, that doesn't make sense. If I had heard about the problem before purchase, I wouldn't have bought it.
I'm hoping Creative can & will release a firmware update that increases the ID tag database storage like the new 60GB unit must have.
Aside from that, the Zen is no Empeg (of course). But it's nice, and portable enough for the gym.
I also have an Archos Jukebox 6000 upgraded to 40GB. The Rockbox software really makes these MUCH nicer.
Posted by: RobotCaleb

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 15:45

ive an ipod and my roommate has a 20 gig zen.
it seems to be pretty nice, easy access of songs. hes kinda messy though so theres not any playlists made. and not many of his songs are labeled correctly. but... it is fairly easy to search through songs and albums. it does auto create them (playlists, that is) from the id3 tags. the jog dial doesnt seem to accelerate so it can be a pain going from the top of a list to the bottom.
the creative EAX dsp modes are fun to listen to (hall, theatre, bathroom, live, opera and others) but the equalizer leaves alot for the wanting. its got your standard presets and a custom mode. only like six or seven (iirc) bars and no way further customization than your standard up and down. (ive now compared it to empeg. of course it wont satisfy me equalizer wise) it can serve as a portable hdd, which is nice, but cant everything these days?
it supports recording through a wired mic, not sure if its included or not, never used it.
umm... not much else off the top of my head.
over all... ipod is smaller and weighs less, is much prettier and has a coo jog dial on the front.
nomad is little heavier, kinda confusing interface at first, has cool sound distortions and i think is cheaper.

both, imo, are overrated. but id pick the ipod over the zen.
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 15:45

Won't the database size be dependent on RAM? It may not be possible to increase it with firmware.

What hard drives will Pearl use? Its too small to use laptop drives so will upgrades be expensive/hard?
Posted by: davekirk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 16:30

Won't the database size be dependent on RAM?
There is some uncertainty on this issue, at least on the forums I visit. AFAIK no Creative employee has definitively answered this as of now. As far as Creative is concerned there is no problem, because they didn't market the Zen to be user storage-upgradeable. A lot of us early purchasers are hoping the problem can be resolved in software, but no one is sure.
The Ipod and (I think) Perl use 1.8" HDD vs 2.5". I haven't heard of anyone who has upgraded the disk in an Ipod. I suspect it's a quantum leap more difficult than the Empeg or Zen. And there's little to be gained in doing an upgrade, since 30GB is the biggest 1.8" HDD model IIRC.
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 17:33

I think rob posted that the pearl uses a smaller than the 1.8" drive the ipod uses
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 17:51

It's certainly a different form factor 1.8" drive than the one in the iPod.

Rob
Posted by: matthew_k

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 17:52

You're thinking of what at some points has been refered to as "slicky" which uses the tiny new hard drives. It is really a tiny player when you see it in person, but from the rumors it's going to be expensive for a a lot less of the storage space of a Pearl/iPod.

Matthew
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/05/2003 19:10

As far as Creative is concerned there is no problem, because they didn't market the Zen to be user storage-upgradeable. A lot of us early purchasers are hoping the problem can be resolved in software, but no one is sure.


I'd guess that Creative's fix will be for you to buy the Zen Gold!
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:21

Rob; I have a question about the Pearl (if you can disclose that information).

Will the HD capacity be comparable, less or larger than the capacity of the (new) iPod?
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:24

Rob, is the design of Pearl finalised? Is the colour scheme still "1970's orange" buttons?
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:29

I believe Rob once said that the chosen colour on the prototype was probably not going to make it in the final product.

Of course, it's possible that they've decided otherwise by now.
Posted by: Jerz

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:35

I just saw an ad in a music magazine a couple of weeks ago that a friend had (I believe it was some kind of Metal magazine) and the pearl had blue buttons and was "coming soon" and price was "TBD". It looked very slick and tiny compared to the ear buds that it was sitting next to. There was no orange on any of the buttons.
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:47

You don't happen to have a scan of it, do you?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:47

Two HDD capacities will be offered, both larger than the equivalent new iPod capacity. The larger capacity is a third larger than the maximum iPod capacity right now.

The colour scheme uses blue buttons. There's no orange anywhere

Rob
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 01:50

I want I want I want I want ! Seriously, if its competitively priced, I'll grab one.
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 02:02

The larger capacity is a third larger than the maximum iPod capacity right now.

That's great! Thanks for the info Rob !
Posted by: Jerz

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 02:32

<<kicking self>> I knew I should have scanned it when I saw it.... I'll see if the guy can bring back the ad and I'll report back.
Posted by: morrisdl

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 05:37

There is a picture of a Pearl in this months Playboy magazine. I dont remember if it had orange or blue buttons. See, I read the articles too.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:00

Since it has been hawked in so many magazines it probably won't hurt to post this image.

Rob
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:03

Nice! Still on for a UK August launch? Maybe?
Posted by: simspos

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:07

In our dreams me thinks,.... It is May & the US ain't got it yet..... D'oh
Posted by: simspos

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:10

Hey Rob, a few players officially sourced through empeg (UK) for the UK masssive / faithfull isn't a possibility is it? (crosses fingers and retires to wait for the inevitable)
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:11

Looks dope! Much better than the model with orange buttons and segmented display. I think I must buy one.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:36

I have no idea about European sales. DNNA haven't formulated their European strategy yet (or at least haven't announced it).

Rob
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 06:47

wow, man that Pearl looks nice!!! I will definately get one.
I kinda have a feeling we wont see this unit before Christmas or so..
I hope im wrong though and still on track for release.
Im also so tired of all of these players boasting these 10-11 hour battery life times, misleading people, not stating that your mp3's gotta be encoded at 64kb, which is a joke.
Rob, can you shed any light on how long the battery life is?
I noticed the screen is pretty big, and backlit.
Excellent design, looks so sharp! man i cant wait to order one!
brian
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:08

I'd be willing to bet my life that its out well before Christmas - its too big a market to lose out on for another year to iPOD. I'll guess August - October time.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:44

It should ship way sooner than Christmas - late summer would be more the target. Stated battery life for our products is based on mid volume 128K MP3, which is a reasonable and fairly common criteria. Obviously you won't get the same battery life if you play 256K Ogg files at full volume the whole time.

We haven't announced the battery life for Pearl yet, however - unofficially - I believe it will be substantially greater than the iPod. The iPod is extremely thin because of its tiny battery, but I think we'll have the better trade off of form factor vs capacity and battery life.

Rob
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:48

Rob-

If you can say (I don't recall seeing it previously), what is the PC/Pearl data connection type (USB2, firewire etc)?

-Zeke
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:50

I remember reading USB 2
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:52

what is the PC/Pearl data connection type

USB 2.0 or 100Mbit Ethernet. One of the Ethernet features is being developed by a well known contributer to the empeg software community, but I couldn't possibly say any more

Rob
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:56

That's perfect. I'm sold!

-Zeke
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 07:59

The Lord has many gifts.
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:03

im drooling now.. ill take the pearl form factor/battery life over less battery life any day.
man, i cant wait.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:13

Rob,
I just wanted to say that that thing looks really cool! I'm sure the software is great too, knowing you guys.
Posted by: cushman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:14

Looks great, Rob! I had forgotten it supports OGG Vorbis. When you guys have a webpage for the Pearl, you should definately get it posted on Slashdot (remember to unplug your coffee maker and plug in your extra webservers). Every story about a new MP3 player always gets 50 bajillion posts to the tune of "Unless it supports OGG, I won't buy it". You guys can give them a big steaming cup of STFU.

Of course you'll also get the posts wanting a color screen, video player, integrated handheld computer, video games, mobile phone, hand lotion dispenser, convert into gas-powered scooter, etc.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:17

Of course you'll also get the posts wanting a color screen, video player, integrated handheld computer, video games, mobile phone, hand lotion dispenser, convert into gas-powered scooter, etc.
You forgot GPS.
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:20

Rob is that early summer date for the US? Could you *guess* at a UK release?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 08:36

I can't even guess at a UK release, as I'm not in the loop with the sales folks on this (too busy developing the products!). Whether it means anything or not, we have been told to go ahead and localise the software for our usual European languages (plus Japanese) in time for release 1.0.

Rob
Posted by: bonzi

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 13:04

we have been told to go ahead and localise the software for our usual European languages (plus Japanese) in time for release 1.0.

So, who is doing Croatian translation?

Seriously, this is the first time I saw the thing, and I can't stop drooling. And, you say, 3.0 SW is the baseline? Fantastic!
Posted by: andy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 18:00

Every story about a new MP3 player always gets 50 bajillion posts to the tune of "Unless it supports OGG, I won't buy it". You guys can give them a big steaming cup of STFU.

I won't stop the normal "why would you want to spend that much money on it ? I could build one myself for 50 cents" posts...
Posted by: tman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 18:16

What? You mean I can't make one from a mini-ITX motherboard and a few rolls of duck tape? It's like that "amazing" video sniffer that was on there recently. Turns out it was the guts of a receiver duck taped to a portable TV and battery...

To be honest, actually reading the comments on a slashdot story is useless half the time. You get about 50 first posts, around 30 useful comments and around 300 trolls. I'm glad that the empeg BBS actually has a non zero signal to noise ratio:)

Anyway, must go to sleep. It's like 2:15am here. Unfortunately my next door neighbour is having some party or something and it's driving me nuts. They're all having a big sing along but it's in Greek so I've got no clue what they're going on about!

- Trevor
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 20:09

To be honest, actually reading the comments on a slashdot story is useless half the time. You get about 50 first posts, around 30 useful comments and around 300 trolls. I'm glad that the empeg BBS actually has a non zero signal to noise ratio:)
And the scary part, people now PAY to read Slashdot stories 20 minutes early. So that instead of being two days out of date, the stories are 1 day, 23 hours, and 40 minutes out of date.

The funny thing is, (and I know Tom wouldn't even consider it) I would gladly pay Slashdot's subscription rates (and then some) if, in some alternate dimension, this BBS were subscription-based. I know many others would do the same.

Funny how things work like that.
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/05/2003 20:49

I could come up with a payment rate, if you'd like.
Posted by: JaBZ

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 11/05/2003 03:26

I want one....
Since sonic blue is gone, where will Rio products be sold from?, new website? Will it allow international ordering?

I'd rather order it from US than UK, as our US exchange rate is healthier I'm in NZ...

Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 10:58

You'll probably have to find a US retailer willing to ship to NZ. There will be a new US eStore at www.rioaudio.com but I don't think the shipping policies will change. I would expect the UK store to close entirely as SONICblue's European sales office turned out the lights today (they were not acquired by DNNA).

I suspect that international sales will start to come online drawing on existing D&M channels but I don't know how soon.

Rob
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 12:35

I'm a latecomer to this thread ... This picture looks much much cooler than the first one you posted a couple months ago. The orange buttons won't be missed.

Are the physical dimensions still the same as shown in http://empeg.comms.net/files/133662-ipodcompare.jpg ?

ms
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 12:41

The dimensions haven't changed.

The first docks arrived here today - very cute! You get line level audio out of the dock, as well as Ethernet, USB and power in.

Rob
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 12:43

a well known contributor, huh ....

fascinating ....
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 12:45

Do we get to see pictures of the dock, or have we pushed our luck already?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/05/2003 15:30

I'll check with marketing. If they're happy I'll post a photo or two.

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:04

They were happy.

This player is missing it's blue thumb wheel thingy but you get the idea.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:05

..and the rear, with coke can for scale.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:05

Please don't repost those pics anywhere else. I got special permission to post them to the empeg BBS.

Rob
Posted by: JBjorgen

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:10

so Rio Karma is Pearl's real name?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:10

It may or may not be, and that may or may not be public knowledge!
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:10

That looks like THE SHIT! Congratulations guys.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:13

Very cool Rob. I wasn't even considering getting another mp3 player since I have my Empeg, but now that I've seen some pics I can see how handy it'd be to have something so small. You can tell your marketing people you might have made a sale if I have the money when the Pearl comes out; too bad you won't get a commission!
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:40

Mmmmmmm.... 100 megabit ethernet port on the back.... RCA jacks..... DROOOOOOOL....
Posted by: Redrum

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 11:54

Cool man.... just don't send out any "Bad Karma" man....
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 12:34

Karma: +5, Dope Ass Shit (Mostly affected by involvement of the Cambridge team)
Posted by: matthew_k

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 12:48

I'm so glad to see that dockable ethernet didn't end up on the cutting room floor as I assumed it would. Can you tell us if the dock going to cost extra? Soon it'll be time to break out the hammer and smash the piggy bank.

Matthew
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 13:52

Interesting...I don't see a DC power input. Does it charge with power from the USB? I think I'll be stashing away some shekels for this puppy.

Drooool.....

-Zeke
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 13:54

Looks like a DC power input on the dock to me, in between the white RCA jack and the USB connector.
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 13:55

That small? It looked too wee to be a DC input.

-Zeke
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 13:57

That small? It looked too wee to be a DC input.
Yeah, and the Pearl/Karma looks too wee to be an MP3 player with many gigs of storage.
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:00

Hey, I can get a USB charger for my PDA & phone, why not do it with this? Everyone hates wall warts.

-Zeke

edit: Not that having a wall wart would dissuade me from purchasing...
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:03

I agree with you in theory, but then people with no USB would be shut out. Bestest solution would be allow power from either, of course.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:05

That small? It looked too wee to be a DC input.
If it's anything like the other recent portable players that Rio's done (such as the S50), it's an extra-small connector, much smaller than what's on the car player.
Posted by: Folsom

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:26

Interesting...I don't see a DC power input

The jack is a mini-USB connector.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:34

Correct, the DC input is the small hole next to the micro USB port. It's that small so we can use the same AC adapter when the player is not docked.

Rob
Posted by: ricin

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:37

Damn, no PoE?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:38

You can only take 500mA from USB - this is not enough to run the player and trickle charge the battery.

500mA is enough to trickle charge a mobile phone, which doesn't have to contend with impulse currents when a hard disk spins up. Even so many mobiles take more, but the USB charger manufacturers don't care about USB compliance.

FYI our other (smaller) new portables do take power from USB.

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:41

Damn, no PoE?

No, sorry, neither of the installed POE users wanted a Pearl

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:43

If it's anything like the other recent portable players that Rio's done (such as the S50), it's an extra-small connector, much smaller than what's on the car player

In fact it's a smaller connector than the S50 one! We are using the same connector on Slate, so it had to be very small! It is a readily available standard, though, and of course you get an AC Adapter with the player.

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:46

I'm so glad to see that dockable ethernet didn't end up on the cutting room floor as I assumed it would. Can you tell us if the dock going to cost extra?

The dock is included with the player. The plan is to sell additional docks, if there's any demand for them (I believe there will be).

Rob
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:46

"...neither of the installed POE users..."

ROFLMAO!

Screen's dry as I'm out of coffee.

-Zeke
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:47

Cool man.... just don't send out any "Bad Karma" man

..so you should probably check out the firmware recovery mode if you get a Pearl

Rob
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:51

FYI our other (smaller) new portables do take power from USB

Ah, so you're also already working on the successor of Pearl ?
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 14:54

I think he means the non-hard drive based portables. You know, CompactFlash, et al.
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 15:14

I think he means the non-hard drive based portables. You know, CompactFlash, et al.
Not necessarily. We saw a really slick one at the West Coast dinner at The Stinking Rose. It was hard disk based, but small as hell. I'm not sure if I should say anything more about it though (capacity).
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 15:22

Slate was discussed with the press at CES so its not all that secret. 1.5GB capacity in a unit substantially smaller than the current flash players.
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 15:31

Cool. Didn't remeber its code name.
Posted by: Daria

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 13/05/2003 16:40

Bah. Way more than that.

I'm tired of having a cord for my Cisco 7940; I really want PoE here.

Which reminds me, I've only used it for SIP calls. I wonder what its phone number is?
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 09:32

How bout this name for the new (Pearl) unit...
-Empeg Jr!-

brian
Posted by: maurij

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 10:21

What do you know about power over ethernet? can any standard ethernet port deliver power? ie could i hook up a wireless bridge to the empeg without a power brick if the bridge supported PoE? do you know if the empeg serial connector delivers power?
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 11:08

How thick is the Pearl? It appears to be fairly large in that respect. Does it support recording? The new iPod will soon be doing so.

Stu
Posted by: trs24

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 11:56

Does it support recording? The new iPod will soon be doing so.
Actually, it already does... sort of.
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 12:29

Yeah I know about that and have tried it, I just don't consider that supporting recording, b/c you have to go into an undocumented diagnostic mode. Background noise is a bit high and of course six seconds is not very useful. Still when they come out with a software update and proper connections, I think the quality will be outstanding, given the specs on the ADC chip. Depending on if they put level meters and gain adjustment into the software, it might even serve as a worthy replacement for my long trashed Sony DAT.

Stu
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 16:10

Pearl is indeed thicker than the iPod, albeit it substantially shorter. We have an entirely different design philosophy (with little details such as a useful battery life) which some people will prefer, while others will go for iPod. I won't even try to convince a Mac fan - I know you guys catch anything Apple deign to throw at you

No plans for recording in version 1.0. There's plenty of headroom, though, as we use the next generation of the chip used in the iPod. Even so I'm not convinced that single speed capture is going to be the killer feature - quality playback features such as the cross fader and fully parametric EQ are more important.

Rob
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/05/2003 16:23

So you are using the WM8731L? Pretty nice.

Stu
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 02:48

Yes, at it happens, but I was actually talking about the processor.

Rob
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 03:55

Actually we use the 8721, not the 31. We have no line inputs. We do, however, have USB host with which to attach ADCs should we want them...

Hugo
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 06:14

little details such as a useful battery life
???

I've never had the first problem with the battery life in my iPod, other than it seems to use it up more quickly than I'd expect lying around turned off.
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 07:24

i forgot to even ask, does it have an FM tuner?
man i hope so!!

brian
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 07:28

My iPod? Nope.
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 08:26

The 8721 is what the iPods used to use, if I remember correctly. So you probably use the built in USB controller on a PortalPlayer PP5002 then right?

Stu
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 10:49

The new iPod has a stated battery life of 8 hours. That means it is going to be somewhat less in reality. A smaller battery was used to shave a couple of mm off the thickness.

Rob
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 10:55

Mine is one of the older ones with a stated life of 10 hours. While I can see people possibly wanting more than that, even given the inflation of the stated spec, I'd have to say that it hardly qualifies as not being ``a useful battery life'', even at 8 (or whatever that means IRL).
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 10:58

I wish all our portable customers thought like that. They're used to CD players with 30 hours of playtime.

Rob
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/05/2003 11:21

A good point. And I actually have one of your portables (for my wife), though I need to get a memory card for it.
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/05/2003 10:42

The 5002 doesn't have a host USB controller. We don't use the 5002.

Hugo
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/05/2003 11:32

Their site says it features an "integrated USB 1.1 Device Controller," but thanks!

Stu
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/05/2003 02:06

Yes, "device controller" is a USB slave (just like the empeg-car); "host controller" is what we have in Pearl

Hugo
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/05/2003 09:11

Very good! I forgot to make that distinction. I obviously don't do much work with USB .

Stu
Posted by: puckalicious

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/05/2003 10:38

Sorry if this was discussed already, but how does the Pearl compare to the new Ipod in terms of mass? I stopped by my local Apple store and played around with an Ipod and it was much heavier than I expected. The posted weight of the Ipod is 5.6g (6.2g for 30Gb) but I think the small size makes me feel like it should be lighter.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/05/2003 12:14

I'm pretty sure you meant ounces.

Rob
Posted by: phi144

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/05/2003 13:33

Amazing design.

Someone else asked this as well. But, will this include an FM tuner?
Posted by: puckalicious

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/05/2003 04:23

Wow is that ridiculously light! Yes I meant ounces. (punching myself)
So, are you able to answer the question?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/05/2003 06:06

I only have postage scales to check with, post they show the Pearl prototype as being exactly the same weight as the smallest iPod. Weight really isn't an issue in either case.

Rob
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 03:01

What are the chances of it appearing somewhere in holland next month
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 03:06

High, considering it's almost in beta now...

Hugo
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 04:10

Any 'unofficial' UK release dates?
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 05:30

Nope, but if you really want one (as usual) get it from the US. They will be getting it first.

Hugo
Posted by: puckalicious

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 10:58

Looks like Rio won't be the only player with a 1.5GB model according to this.

Twelve companies so far have plans to release products with the drive. RCA/Thomson, Rio and five other manufacturers will come out with MP3 players with the Cornice Storage Element (SE), and a major U.S. retailer will feature a Cornice-based player from Korea. The first products will hit shelves this quarter, according to Cornice.

Looks like alot of competition for the 1.5GB model, what about Pearl??
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 11:09

dont think this was answered yet..
Does the Pearl have the FM tuner?

b
Posted by: Dignan

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 13:49

I'm sorry, I'm sure I just missed it, but what is the PC interface, software-wise??
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 14:06

No tuner in Pearl.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/06/2003 14:09

I'm sorry, I'm sure I just missed it, but what is the PC interface, software-wise??

Rio Music Manager 2 (a huge move forward from RMM 1) will give the cutest features, otherwise WMP, Real One, anything that supports WMDM, or some nifty Ethernet stuff that I'm not talking about yet but which should be pretty easy to guess (think: multiplatform).

Rob
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 01:52

huge move forward from RMM1 you say but what is it like in comparison to emplode.

Big question can i organise music the same way as an empeg as in i control the playlists and i can have one song copied to many different places but still have only one copy of the song.


Also if we bribe you with beer and food could you talk very nicely to somebody somewhere to get a few for the empeg faithful?
Posted by: pache

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 02:21

No tuner in Pearl.

That's a realy bad news. Well, maybe not for everybody, but for me it's a bad news.
Even if I have thousand of musics on my player, sometime I want to listen to radio, for news and hits of the moment.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 04:24

I don't think I've seen a tuner inside any hard disk portable. I daresay there must be one but none spring to mind. This is probably because the reception sucks when you stick a tuner right next to an IDE bus and a fast processor in a very small enclosure, and sucky tuners do more harm than good to sales.

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 04:29

The music organisation in a completely different philosophy to the car player. Where as the car player had almost no intelligence in music selection on the unit and left everything to the user as a manual process on the PC, Pearl has all the intelligence in the database but provides only for flat manual playlists. Yes, the ideal solution would be to have both, but if you only have time to do one of them for 1.0 then the empeg system isn't saleable and the Soup/RioDJ system is.

We do have one of the best running order editors I've seen on any portable, though.

If any non-US BBS people want to get a Pearl I can look into some kind of group purchase when players are shipping.

Rob
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 05:47

I don't think I've seen a tuner inside any hard disk portable. I daresay there must be one but none spring to mind.
Maybe you missed the memo about the Riot?

Also, this thing.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 07:24

I have erased the Riot from memory. It's the only proper thing to do.

Besides, I said "inside a very compact case"

Rob
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 11:02

yea, i agree No Tuner is very bad news. I think thats almost a necessity these days.
Almost all the new players are having it. Not all but, more and more.... very bad news for me, i was holding out for the pearl.
might have to look elsewhere now. i really want an FM tuner in my player. dam, this really blows!
b
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 15:45

I couldn't care less about a tuner. All they every put in are FM and the only stations I listen to are AM anyway.

I wouldn't say the tuner is necessary the all mighty ipod has no tuner and no one will say anything bad about it. (other than it costs too much)

Posted by: pache

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 17:35

All they every put in are FM and the only stations I listen to are AM anyway.

Maybe in the states but here in europe I assure you that FM don't only have FM music. And for me it's important to have live news (you know radios don't only provides musics).

I wouldn't say the tuner is necessary the all mighty ipod has no tuner and no one will say anything bad about it. (other than it costs too much)

Well, that's the main reason I don't have an iPod yet, thought I'm an Apple addict.
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 18:20

No Almost all music stations (large boring corporate) are on FM. When I listen to the radio it usually the local collage station which is on AM.
Posted by: maczrool

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 19:19

All the college stations here are on FM, but I never really cared for them anyway.

Stu
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/06/2003 22:26

A tuner in a product for me equates to "cheap" - a no sale. Glad one isn't in the Karma.

You can buy a portable micro-sized radio for less than a buck, with headphones, in bulk (sure, maybe a container full). But on a scale most people can handle, you can pick one up from one vendor or another at any tech-related tradeshow as a giveaway. Yeah, this is an extreme example showing how cheap a tuner can be.

I think te Pearl is small enough that you can carry two products. What CURRENT product do people use that has both a tuner and radio receiver?

Radio died in 1993 (or maybe it was 1991). The only reason I ever switch to tuner in the car is to avoid having my amps pop when I insert my empeg.

Now if people want to complain that it doesn't play video, then I'm all ears.

Bruno
Posted by: pache

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 05:25

I think te Pearl is small enough that you can carry two products.

I already carry two products, a mobile phone (SonyEricsson P800) and a PocketPC. The P800 do play MP3, but actually the max memory it 64mb (it's a lot for a phone, but not enough for a MP3 player). I use my PocketPC also for playing MP3, but it didn't have enough storage memory for me (4 albums in 256mb) and the battery last only a day while I'm using it like a player . I don't use moving part memory (Microdrive or Toshiba drive like the iPod) to avoid even shorter battery life.
I was thinking to buy a new product : the Pearl, so I don't want a fourth one to carry around.
Some mobile do have radio inside (Nokia, Samsung, Siemens) but not the P800 .

What CURRENT product do people use that has both a tuner and radio receiver?

What do you mean by this? A tuner could also be used to receive VHF TV signal and a radio could also be used like a receiver/transmitter (like a CB or a walkie-talkie). For me when I say "radio" I mean a radio to receive FM/AM station.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:00

Well, that's the main reason I don't have an iPod yet, thought I'm an Apple addict.

On the other hand a HUGE number of people do have an iPod, so statistically I think we're on fairly safe ground. These decisions are based on market research - some of our new products have a tuner because enough potential customers want one, but they are the lower end products.

Rob

Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:20

Radio died in 1993 (or maybe it was 1991).


Bruno, Radio died in 1991? what planet are you living on?
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:23

what planet are you living on?
Canada.
Posted by: mlord

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:30

Which is really weird, as in Canada we actually have comercial-free radio (CBC), as well as good reception of the USA NPR stations in most areas!

I listen 80% to radio, 20% to historic audio (aka. prerecorded MP3s on my player).

Cheers
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:41

The only radio I ever listen to is talk radio. In fact, I got so tired of the same repetitious songs and annoying DJ’s that I stopped listening to music on the radio even before I got my Empeg. No, radio is not a necessary or even desired feature for me.
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 06:43

Bruno, Radio died in 1991? what planet are you living on?
Really. It was at least five years earlier than that.

I seriously haven't listened to any significant amount of radio since, probably, 1987. I'd pretty much gotten sick of the dozen songs they play by that point in my life.
Posted by: pache

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 07:00

These decisions are based on market research

Yes, I already notice that I'm not part of the HUGE part of population. Some hint :
- I have 2 empeg,
- but don't have a car
- I use cable and ADSL for connecting to the net at home
- I use a Mac and a PC at home (only PC at work)
- at work I use COBOL language
- my mother is from US, my grandmother is form Russia, I was born in Africa and I leave in Switzerland
- I still listen to radio
- and my shoes are dark.
Posted by: Taym

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 07:03

I don't think I would ever be even able to listen to music on the radio. I can't find what I like when I like it...

On the other hand I listen to the radio every morning while going to work. It has become a nice habit, but only because there's a radio station I really like that broadcasts talks about current int'l news and interviews and comments which I find brilliant and interesting. I don't think I'd ever want to give up that, now.

Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 07:37

well, it sounds like we have a split on the radio issue.. which makes the point that it is NOT such an off the wall feature that only the "Low End" user would want.
Rob, how much would it drive the price up of the unit if an FM tuner was built in?
Why not pack it with as many features as possible?
is the overhead that much more?

b
Posted by: davekirk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 12:10

I don't think I've seen a tuner inside any hard disk portable. I daresay there must be one but none spring to mind. -rob
For the record, Archos makes a hard disk player with FM tuner built in. Creative's Jukebox and Zen players have a plug-in remote unit which also provides an FM tuner.
I happen to agree with your position, though. Radio here is crap and it wouldn't matter to me whether there's a tuner.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 12:56

The only reason I'd want radio on the Karma would be if had weatherband, so that I'd be able to find out if God decided to piss on me whilst I was jogging (yeah...like that'd ever happen).

I'd much rather see other features. Such as 10m water resistance. That would be useful.
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 14:24

Arse doesn't have the empeg playlist system

Any chance of it making it over to 2.0 karma otherwise it might be bad karma but i shall reserve judgement till i get my sticky mitts on one ,as sexy the ipod is the music selection system sucks in comparisson to the empeg.

How about other features like the insert features of the empeg giviing you a dynamic playlist for the want of another term.

As to the group buy for the BBs folk here in europe i would sign up for one. If not i have two recivers so it isn't immpossible but a group buy would be very appreciated
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 14:29

as sexy the ipod is the music selection system sucks in comparisson to the empeg.
Keep in mind that the Empeg Car is the only product that has the hierarchical playlist system. Not even the Rio Central has hierarchical playlists. I wish it did.
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 15:08

It seems there IS a way to get FM now on the iPod. Ok, so it's not built-in, but it's a good option. See here.
Posted by: BartDG

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 15:09

Keep in mind that the Empeg Car is the only product that has the hierarchical playlist system. Not even the Rio Central has hierarchical playlists. I wish it did.

I'm still hoping it will be a 2.0 feature. Rob already said it might be.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 17:01

How about other features like the insert features of the empeg giviing you a dynamic playlist for the want of another term.

We've built on that. Pearl has a comprehensive running order editor which lets you save out the running order as a playlist if you want.

Hierarchical playlists are a logical upgrade so I'd anticipate they'll show up at some point. If they do we could put car player support into RMM2 which would be nice

Rob
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 17:35

And of course this one will sync with the central right
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 19:28

Oops. I didn't mean both tuner and receiver. Same thing. I meant tuner and MP3 player...

Bruno
Posted by: Udders

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/06/2003 22:22

> If any non-US BBS people want to get a Pearl I can look into some kind of group purchase when players are shipping.

If this is possible, and would include those of us who are a little further afield, then count me in...
I'm NZ and am holding out for Pearl's release, have bought a CD MP3 player(iRiver SlimX) to see me through until I can get my hands on the real thing...!

Duncan

p.s. I like FM tuners too, for traffic, weather, sporting events, and hearing new music, but as Rob said, it's a market research thing (and a fait accompli from what I gather) and I ain't gonna cry about it... :-P
Posted by: furtive

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 02:32

In reply to:

If any non-US BBS people want to get a Pearl I can look into some kind of group purchase when players are shipping.




Yes please
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 02:36

Oh central doesn't have hierarchical playlists i thought it was almost identical to the empeg
Posted by: windchill

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 08:37

This would be great.
I am definetely interested in such a group buy!

Marc
Posted by: mtempsch

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 10:52

If any non-US BBS people want to get a Pearl I can look into some kind of group purchase when players are shipping.


Anotherone interested here...

/Michael
Posted by: juenk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 12:11

> If any non-US BBS people want to get a Pearl I can look into some kind of group purchase when players are shipping.

I'm interested as well (depending on the final $$)

Jelle
Posted by: Redrum

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/06/2003 12:19

Bruno, perhpas you'd like this one...

http://www.msnbc.com/news/921628.asp

Oh, wait, has a tuner, must be "cheap."
Posted by: Mataglap

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 12/06/2003 13:17

I'm going to getting one (and a second base), and mostly because of the Ogg support! Make moving audio files a whole bunch easier between home and the office. The pictures are cool, thanks for posting them.

Two questions: First, will the built-in playlist software have the ability to randomly songs (either randomly sort the playlist or randomly pick the next song without repeating or playing too much from the same artist or album in a row)? Second, with the USB port will I be able to see it as an extra hard drive on my computer? (This way I can use foobar2000 as the player but store all the files on the Pearl?)

Thanks!

--Nathan
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/06/2003 07:24

So, Rob, which flavor of USB 2.0 will the Pearl support?
Posted by: peter

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/06/2003 09:21

So, Rob, which flavor of USB 2.0 will the Pearl support?
The non-fraudulently-deceptive kind.

Peter
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/06/2003 20:50

It's from Archos. It's going to be crap. There are a number of companies that were onboard to release portable video players and/or recorders this year. Including one former SonicBlue... We'll see how tings are shaping up by the end of the year. Any device like this should most definitely support compact flash (for on-the-road image unloading), but yes, radio would be only a waste of space - internally and possibly a mis-use of buttons.

Bruno
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 19/06/2003 22:09

Rob, I haven't noticed mentoined before, but, excluding the dock, what are the connectos on the actual Pearl/Karma unit itself? I'm curious to know what provisions there are for connection to a computer wihtout using the dock, if any. For things like file taxi, syncing when traveling without the dock, etc. Also if it has a charging connector on it (which I can't recall). I just noticed for the first time that the new iPods have eliminated the Firewire port and have gone to a dock connector only. Though they sell cables with a dock connector on one end and either firewire or USB connector on the other.

Umm, I don't suppose such a cable (to suport IEEE1394) could be made for the Rio, eh? ) Sort of sure I remember reading the chip used was USB only.

Bruno
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 02:17

On the top:

- Headphone/wing remote

On the bottom:

- Mini USB2.0 (standard mini USB cable)
- Dock
- DC power in

No chance of a firewire port I'm afraid, you'll have to be satisfied with ethernet

Hugo
Posted by: durden

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 11:14

I know that this has been asked before, but do we have any idea on how far back the release date for this is going to be? I'm dying to buy one.. Are we talking like within a month, or more like within 4 months?
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 12:35

Are we talking like within a month, or more like within 4 months?

Somewhere between the two.

Rob
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 13:30

OOooppps Robs given a date that means sudden unknown delay will turn up
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 15:35

If it does then Rob will be out of a job.

Rob
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 20/06/2003 15:42

If it does then Rob will be out of a job.
Hopefully they'll only hold you responsible for delays that really are your responsibility. Because I know that there's already been a delay that's got nothing to do with you guys, or anyone within Rio for that matter.
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/06/2003 07:44

Hugo, will there be a connection kit for my Commodore 64?

Yeah, I guess one would just have to *live* with ethernet. It does seem like you guys have a winner on your hands, so let's hope it gets marketed effectively and priced aggressively. A couple of people at work have just bought iPods nd only because this cool new rio product I told them about a month ago isn't out yet (I did tell them it would be later in the summer).

Nwo who's going to make the first IR receiver for it?

I'd love to see a small unit like this plug into a port on a head unit that would otherwise conceal the portable behind a full face VFD. Mmmm. Sweet.

Bruno
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 22/06/2003 10:37

Hugo, will there be a connection kit for my Commodore 64?


What? You mean that you _want_ to wait 10 minutes for a single download and _then_ get told that it failed?
Posted by: pache

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/06/2003 04:15

I just find this one, with 10Gb disk AND FM tuner.

http://www.iriver.com/company/news_view.asp?idx=342

Posted by: mlord

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/06/2003 07:43

If it does then Rob will be out of a job.

I suppose he could always find work as a DJ for Chinese Music CDs.

(don't ask)
Posted by: mlord

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/06/2003 09:05

Yes, "device controller" is a USB slave (just like the empeg-car); "host controller" is what we have in Pearl

Any chance of perhaps allowing Pearl to accept USB mass-storage slaves, and act as a photo data-dump from my USB CF reader(s). It's way smaller than the Digial Wallet thingie I currently lug around..

Cheers
Posted by: mschrag

Nyah Nyah - 26/06/2003 11:24

It's too bad that anyone who has one of these units would probably be under NDA and wouldn't be able to talk about just how very very cool they are.
Posted by: mlord

Re: Nyah Nyah - 26/06/2003 11:38

Maybe RobV will show off some of them at Amersfoort.. good enough reason to attend even if nothing else was happening there that weekend!

Cheers
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Nyah Nyah - 26/06/2003 11:50

Well if they bring along the dj related thingy again i would like to see how that is doing it was a nice toy, would never want one but it was impressive.

The main reason i am going is incase a karma turns up
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Nyah Nyah - 26/06/2003 12:02

The main reason i am going is incase a karma turns up
Oh, I think you can count on that.
Posted by: Phoenix42

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 30/06/2003 11:59

Okay, so the first month has gone...just three more at most to go.
Fingers crossed.

PS Any additional info on the Slate? other then it using a 1.5GB drive.
Posted by: miko

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/07/2003 11:37

Will it run linux? WIll I be able to play with it?
Posted by: gbeer

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/07/2003 21:07

1 to 4 mos sounds like 03 xmas sales season for sure. I'll take the day after thanksgiving in the pool.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 11:22

Are there any problems with the betas that would cause any delays?
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 20:09

Nah...it'd take me more than a month to convince my wife to buy me one for Christmas, and I doubt that I'm alone in that boat. I also figure that if I were to buy myself one 1 month before Christmas then I'd probably be in the doghouse too. If, however, they released it 3 months before Christmas, then it gives me 1 month to see whether the Christmas thing might work, and failing that, another month to buy it myself before the pre-Christmas budget takes effect. So my guess is sometime in mid-September. I'll take the 15th in the pool
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 20:40

I heard that the betas were buggy and that the release is postponed until further notice.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 21:35

I heard that the betas were buggy and that the release is postponed until further notice.


Who'd'ya hear that from?
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 23:16

It was posted on another forum by a pretty knowledgeable person of HDD-players but not affiliated with any companies. His name is Robert and he's the European staff member of dapReview.com, otherwise known as one of the only comprehensive Digital Audio Player Review sites. He and his American counterpart keep up with this type of stuff, and I assume he received that information from one of the developers or someone close to this project. Unless you are a total Rio-enthusiast, check it out and look around. There are more competitors to the iPod than you may think. One that is going to be released probably sometime in August is the iRiver (famous for their CD-MP3 players) iHP-100, which has only a drawback of capacity size (10 GB only for now, there is speculation they'll be releasing the iHP-200, which boasts 20 GB). But the features are extraordinary: 16 hour battery life, pretty much the size and weight of the iPod, included remote with an LCD screen on it, FM tuner, built-in recording capabilities, optical line-in/out, 8-line screen display, USB 2.0 transfer, etc. You can find out more about its specifications here. There are also other competitors joining in the HDD-player roundup including Philips, Multichannel Labs, Samsung, Now Evolution, and so on. Seems like soon enough there'll be an HDD-player to suit almost everyone (because of each player's diversity in features, cost, size, etc.)
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 23:21

Are any of the competitors going to allow you to build a playlist on the fly ? (insert and append)

That is a feature that has been lacking on every player I have looked at except my empeg and my rio central.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 23:33

I'm not exactly sure but I thought that the only one that I've known not have this feature is the 2nd generation iPods.

I'm pretty sure it's an important feature that Apple has now implemented it in their newer 3rd generation iPods, and other companies allow them as well.
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 23:47

I didn't even know apple added that I knew the first gen ones didn't have it. All the reviews I have seen (not too many) don't mention that feature has been added all they seem to care about are the new touch sensitive buttons big wow. I'm starting to think many people don't want / can comprehend insert and append.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/07/2003 23:59

... and there are plenty of people who actually hate the new touch sensitive buttons because they now have to always put it on "Hold" mode to prevent it from activating any buttons...

Anyway, yeah, they added it, here's an excerpt from an article from CNET: "... the On The Go function--our favorite addition--enables you to create a new playlist even when the iPod isn't attached to a computer..."
Posted by: drakino

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:00

We should know soon, since we have several members of the board mingling at the Europe meet with the developers.

And sure, while other players might be on the market, one of the big reasons we like the empeg is the software. Nothing comes close to it, and I won't be able to tolerate a portable HDD player that is less flexable next to my empeg.

I wasn't a total Rio enthusiast until the empeg folks became the only Rio engineers left.

I'll leave you with a fair warning. Most members have an almost religious fanacisitm about the empeg. With that said, no matter how heated a discussion gets, we are all mature here, and so don't take anything personally :-)
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:07

The eDigital Odyssey 1000, Bantam BA1000, and the iPods from the 2nd generation do not have on-the-fly playlists. The Creative Labs ones (Nomad Jukebox 3 and Nomad Zen) both have on-the-fly playlists. I believe that the Neuros, Multichannel Labs (Xclef) should also have it too, but not sure. The ones I'm not sure about are the iRiver iHP-100, Philips HDD100, and Rio Karma? I'm sure they have playlist support, just not sure if it's on-the-go. Oh, MamboX products (not sure if all, but at least some) also have on-the-go playlists. This information is probably not that much help to you, but anyway...
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:09

I think there are many ipod fanatics on here. How many of the empeg guys have ipods now

Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:11

Yes, I don't personally own any Rio or Empeg products, but I have heard that the software is the best. I think I've read from IGN that the Rio Riot (which the developers of the Rio Karma have forgotten about haha) had great software, but not so great hardware (I notice, it's huge).

I can't wait to hear any news about this player. I like competition.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:13

I'm not one of the "Empeg guys" but I'm receiving an iPod soon to give to someone as a gift hehe (but not before I play around with it first hahaha).
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 00:22

I have a Riot. It's ok but it doesn't have insert / append. The software for the riot was made by different people than the Karma.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 01:43

Oh, well then I guess it's just a coincidence that they both have great software, just one is a bit further on the hardware side.

Yay! I got the 200th reply in this thread!
Posted by: peter

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 02:41

I think I've read [...] that the Rio Riot [...] had great software
I don't think I ever heard, during the entire development of Karma, anyone saying "it's got to be loads better than the Riot software". I think we all just took it for granted...

Peter
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 06:39

Another feature that the Rio Karma won't have (initially) is nested playlists like the Empeg. However, there has been some hinting (has there really? Am I being wishful?) that it may get them in the future. This will really set it apart from the pack, I believe, but I suppose we'll just have to see.

For me, I don't need a portable yet. But if I do buy one it'll be from these guys. I have never been as impressed with anything I've ever purchased as much as the Empeg an it's software, so they've earned quite a bit of goodwill from me.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 13:06

It was posted on another forum by a pretty knowledgeable person of HDD-players

..who doesn't know what he's talking about. The project is on schedule.

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 13:08

Are any of the competitors going to allow you to build a playlist on the fly ?

Yes, Pearl has two different interfaces to do this. One is like the Riot playlist builder, and the other is like the car player but with a "Save running order as playlist" feature (which is what I think you're talking about).

Rob
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 20:22

Did you miss the competitors part

I was talking about being able to do insert and append like on the empeg/central. The only players I have found that do this are made by you guys.

But I guess the ipod does it too now.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 06/07/2003 22:54

Ah okay that's good to hear.

By the way, how shockproof is the unit going to be? Both in playback and just in physical condition... and what materials will it be composed of? Plastic? Rubber? Just stuff I'm wondering about.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 08/07/2003 21:29

Bump? Haha.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/07/2003 03:41

Yes, plastic and rubber. It will be as shockproof as you would expect from a hard disk player with a large cache.

Rob
Posted by: jmwking

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/07/2003 06:52

OK - I'll bite. Just how large will the cache be?

-jk
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 09/07/2003 06:58

Big?

<ducks and runs for cover>
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/07/2003 21:57

Bump again. Argh there needs to be a Rio Karma discussion board/forum somewhere where it's all dedicated to people who are more interested in this.

I can't decide if I want to get this or wait for the iRiver iHP-200 which is loaded with features (20 GB hard drive, FM tuner, 16 hours battery life, only a tiny bit bigger/heavier than 3rd generation iPod, comes with remote with an LCD screen, firmware upgradeable which iRiver is pretty good at releasing, recording with built-in microphone, USB 2.0 file transfer, optical in and out, magnesium body, etc.)

Of course I probably don't need all of these features, but it'd be cool just to have them in case I ever am bored. I love gadgets.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/07/2003 22:11

Argh there needs to be a Rio Karma discussion board/forum somewhere where it's all dedicated to people who are more interested in this.


Hmm. I doubt that many of us here are exactly dis-interested. Face it, we're all pretty crazy about our empegs, and we _know_ what talent the Empeg LTD guys have. In other words we're being patient. We know that they will tell us infomation when they can, and that Rob will start dropping hints when we forget to prod for it.

Of course, your idea is still valid. If the Karma sells like we all hope it does, a support forum will be needed.

Of course I probably don't need all of these features, but it'd be cool just to have them in case I ever am bored.

Fair enough. I personally prefer to have a gadget where the features continue to wow me after 18 months of ownership, rather than one with mediocre core features and lots of surface-shallow bling-bling features that get boring after a day.
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 14/07/2003 23:23

I too am eagerly awaiting the release of this portable... I currently own an Archos and I love it. It's flexibility is a little more suited to my needs than the one Empeg is working on, but I love the empeg's browsing features. I'm spinning like a top trying to decide if I want to wait and see what the Karma is like, or bite the bullet and upgrade the hard drive in the Archos to the 60-80GB level...

Posted by: msandrews

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 01:13

What do you mean when you say the archos has more flexibility than the pearl?
Posted by: JBjorgen

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 07:53

Anyone else think it's a little weird that they their player is named Karma when Creative's is named Zen. Did I miss the memo on the eastern religion naming fad?
Posted by: peter

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 07:56

Did I miss the memo on the eastern religion naming fad?
Remind me in a few product releases' time to tell you a funny story about that.

Peter
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 12:40

Well, I hope I am wrong...

The archos uses a standard laptop drive that can be swapped out quite easily. The Pearl is using some special Micro Drive, correct?

Also, the Archos requires zero software to load music and/or data files. I can load music on it anywhere without emplode, or music match, or whatever.

The downside is the Archos has a very limited UI for managing tracks. We all know how empeg excels in this area. I haven't personally been swayed by the current crop of hard drive portables for these reasons... I'm waiting for Karma/Pearl/What ever it is called this week to try and change my mind.


Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 13:16

I hate going to empeg meets as you don't know what you meant to know
Posted by: brendan

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 16:49

Re: Archos

There's an open source effort that's replaced the firmware on the archos with something substantially better here:

http://rockbox.haxx.se

They've added, among a ton of other things, on the fly playlist modifications/enqeue, etc.

It has made the archos much more usable.

-brendan
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 15/07/2003 17:25

"I hate going to empeg meets as you don't know what you meant to know..."

Is that english?
I hope that means you know something and want to set me straight. I hope, but I think you're full of it... Yep. Full of it. Prove me wrong...

And brendan... Thanks, I have been using RockBox for sometime now, but I had not noticed those items you mentioned. I'll have to check out the recent builds immediately!
Posted by: purpleshorts

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 11:38

I just got the 30 gig iPod, and I really like it. The ability to take every CD I own with me while I work out, or mow the lawn, or take a walk... it's amazing. And the iTunes software makes it incredibly fast and easy to RIP music, build a series of playlists, and then instantaneously upload all changes to the iPod. I also like Apple's new music store. I can find an old song I liked, and buy it for a dollar. I still use Amazon for my CD purchases - that way I have an instant hard copy - but if there's only one or two songs I need, Apple music store gets my dollar.

My only quibble with iPod is the headphones. Apple is the master of user-interface design, so it comes as some surprise that their headphones ignore the shape of human ears. Designed by euclidian geometry rather than human form, these ear buds hurt. I replaced mine wtih some soft rubber Sony ear buds that feel and sound fantastic.

Perhaps the other MP3 players are good too, but I have not tried them. If you already own a Mac, the iPod is the clear choice. I somehow doubt the others can compete with Apple's complete solution. I like having one system that allows me to manage all my music effortlessly, from ripping CDs, to organizing playlists, to burning CDs, to buying single tracks of music... this device (working with my Mac) lets me do it all, and then carry it all around with me where ever I go.

If you get an iPod, I also recommend the Belkin car adapter. It plays iPod through the tape deck, and charges the iPod battery as you drive. I use mine all the time. I have kids, and if they're in the car, I can flip to one of their playlists. Driving alone, I'm back to my stuff.

Summary: If you love music and you love simplicity, you'll love the iPod. Although I use it with a Mac, it works with Windows, too.
Posted by: thinfourth2

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 11:52

erm MP3 in car now there is a novel idea, nah will never catch on.
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 11:56

But, wait! There's more!

Now how much would you pay?
Posted by: cushman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 12:08

Wow, this iPod thing sounds so cool for car use! I've been looking for something I can use to play my MP3's in the car for a long time now, and this seems to be it! You can actually SWITCH playlists with this device?

P.S. What does the Unofficial Empeg Car/RioCar BBS stand for? Kind of a weird name for discussion of new portable MP3 players.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 12:10

If you get an iPod, I also recommend the Belkin car adapter. It plays iPod through the tape deck, and charges the iPod battery as you drive. I use mine all the time. I have kids, and if they're in the car, I can flip to one of their playlists. Driving alone, I'm back to my stuff.


I suspect that I wouldn't bother. Can't see the need.
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 12:36

The effusiveness could have nothing to do with your employer's(DesignAccess) client list, could it?
-Zeke
Posted by: foxtrot_xray

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 12:36

In reply to:


I suspect that I wouldn't bother. Can't see the need.



Yeah, me neither. I have this really cool head unit called an 'Empeg'.. Actually, mine's a RioCar, but same thing, really..

Me.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 13:27

From http://www.designaccess.com/index.asp ;
Design Access designs and develops custom e-learning and marketing communications solutions that solve our customer's business problems and achieve measurable business results

That was certainly a 'custom' marketing communication! Now if someone would tell me exactly what e-learning solutions are I'd be happy. Does it involve an RJ45 implant?
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 13:29

E-learning, that's easy:

Step 1: Create vague website.
Step 2: ?????
Step 3: PROFIT!!!

See?
-Zeke
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 13:43

No, no, no. The /. thread is in the Off Topic forum.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 13:47

So we've had iRiver, Apple... anyone from Creative want a go?

I think I'll bow out of this thread now and let Karma talk for itself in the near future.

Rob
Posted by: peter

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 14:19

So we've had iRiver, Apple... anyone from Creative want a go?
Yeah, I'm shocked -- shocked -- that a company would resort to astroturfing discussion sites to promote a new MP3 player...

Peter
Posted by: Mach

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 15:21

I bought a first generation Ipod. The big pluses for me were size, hardware interface (wheel control...yes I like it), and file shuttle. More times than I can count I've used it with my windows laptop and firewire card to move files around (mostly oracle dump files).

That being said, to say it works with Windows is a bit of a stretch. I've had to hack around the fact that Apple prefers to make me wait for Windows compatible updates and then short sheets the functionality.

When Karma is available, I'll punt the Ipod to Ebay and never look back.
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 17:56

No! Come back and drop subtle hints!

...or should I take that as a subtle hint that release is imminent?

(PS: I downloaded that new Archos software. I can't figure out the playlist functions, but it comes with Othello! Weee!)
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 19:08

I think I'll bow out of this thread now and let Karma talk for itself in the near future.
You heard it here first, folks, the Karma will have text-to-speech capaabilities!

"I'm sorry, Dave, I can't play that Britney Spears track.."
Posted by: jets

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 19:33

I really like my Rio S30S. It only came with 64MB of internal memory but it's miniscule and fits on my arm comforably while running like a madman. I bought a 256MB SD card so I have enough music for a workout with variety. Very neat product I must say...
Posted by: brendan

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 21:15

Re: archos playlist functions

For the daily builds, reading the mailing list archive on the site and/or well, that's about it for documentation between versions.

-brendan
Posted by: JBjorgen

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 21:41

Sounds like they need a Tony Fabris. If ours wasn't so busy, perhaps we'd consider renting him out.
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 16/07/2003 23:13

"For the daily builds, reading the mailing list archive on the site and/or well, that's about it for documentation between versions."

Arg... I was really afraid of that. I was digging through the news group stuff today in the hopes I would find some reference. All I could find was a lot of talk about features, but no real meat.

It really makes me appreciate this community. I have a bit of a gadget weakness. A lot of the ones I get suckered into buying have little to no support beyond the basics. I tip my merlot to the guys at empeg, and our faq master and friends for all your help.

That's why I personally am in such a conundrum over this Karma thing. I know it will be a fine piece of hardware/software, with a high potential for great community support. But my question remains, will it suit me better than my Archos at 60-80GB? The suspense is killing me... I have several friends who look to me for advice on these things. One bought an Archos when I did. Besides the fact that it is a homely thing, he agrees with me on its usefulness. One bought a Zen and got really annoyed with the software. Then he got an iPod. After all the trouble he's had with that, I think he's realizing that it has it's own weird quirks.

bah... I guess I will have to wait and see... Perhaps another glass of wine while I wait...
Posted by: furtive

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 17/07/2003 08:07

How near is that future getting? I'm going to the US at the end of August, and it if's for sale out there by then, I'll be able to spend some money...
Posted by: eliceo

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 17/07/2003 08:10

I think everyone would like to know when, as I am dying to part with my money for one. The toughest choice will be what 40 gigs of music to put on the player. Also will supply be an issue here in the US?
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 17/07/2003 14:27

Sorry -- Tony's got a Karma already and you can bet he'll be visiting the Unofficial Karma BBS when it goes up
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 17/07/2003 18:08

The FAQs probably already at V2.3alpha2. And I bet you he's got every entry bookmarked, ready for the lightening fast responses.
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 18/07/2003 01:44

Is the group purchase thing still a possibility for the non-US guys?
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/07/2003 13:07

It's probably still on but since the final release date for the player hasn't been announced, I don't know how long it'll be after the release in the U.S. in which they'll do group purchase for people outside the U.S.

By the way, who's Tony and what is this all about? I don't know Empeg inside jokes hehe.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/07/2003 13:10

By the way, who's Tony and what is this all about?
Me, and the Hokey Pokey. In that order.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/07/2003 13:10

Err hmm I think I figured it out sort of. Does he write the FAQs for Empeg/Rio products?

I want to play around with a Karma.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/07/2003 13:12

By the way, who's Tony and what is this all about?
Should that be in the FAQ?
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 21/07/2003 13:28

I want to play around with a Karma.


Get in line behind the rest of us.
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 23/07/2003 18:27

dam, i need a new player real bad, my old NEO Jukebox 2 is on its last legs, and the new IPOD looks soo slick, and its going for about $350 for a 15GB player.. I dunno if i can wait for the Karma!!

brian
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 04:10

<Bart> Are we there yet? </Bart>

<Homer> Just a little further... </Homer>

If you get the iPod now, you may be regretting it in the near future... And even if <herecy> you don't like the Karma </herecy>, the extra competition and time would drive the iPod's price down further.
Posted by: eliceo

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 08:05

so how are you going to go from 160 gb --> 40 gb ? Too bad we dont know a range for avaliability for pearl/karma. Shouldnt stores put it in their catalogs or inventories a couple of months before retail though?
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 08:17

damm.. 15 GB is more than enough for me.. what anyone can do with 160 GB of mp3's is beyond me. but thats just my opinion..
and as far as waiting to buy a player, well thats always gonna be the case in the electronics industry. always gonna be a newer,better, and cheaper model out.. we all know that
did we get any kind of price range for the karma yet? im hoping its cheaper than the IPOD, although nothing can compete with the sleek design of the ipod, no denying that.

brian
Posted by: mwest

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 08:40

Most people that I've seen pegging out anything over 120 GB are either audiobook people or they are ripping at a very high bit rate.
Posted by: wfaulk

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 08:49

Keep in mind that even at maximum mp3 bitrate (320kbps), 120GB of storage is about 1000 CDs, assuming a 50 minute CD length on average.

A more sane average of about 200kbps yields enough space for 1600 CDs.

Hell, even recording full-on WAVs, that's enough space for 450 CDs.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 08:54

I thought I'd never need more than 10 gigs, and I probably would have been right if I hadn't started putting on audio books and my wife's country music. Also I keep putting on full albums whether I like all the songs or not, just so I have them for whatever reason (which I probably wouldn't do on the Pearl).

Even at that I'm still under 30 gigs, though if I keep putting on audio books I'll eat that up quickly. Audio books, however, make more sense in the car than on a portable like the Pearl. Or rather if you put them on the Pearl, you won't need more than one on at a time. I suppose the same could be said for the car player too, but as long as I have the space I'll keep loading it up!
Posted by: tman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 09:03

When ever I've had audiobooks on my empeg I've had the bitrate fairly low. 128kbps was good enough for me and it should allow you have a fair bit on there. Music however I have at 192+ because the artifacts drive me nuts. Annoyingly, I never used to notice the artifacts until somebody pointed them out. Now I can spot them a mile off!
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 09:08

Yeah, you can do them fairly low. However, some of them are really loooong. LOTR is 46 CDs and the last Harry Potter book is 23. Someday I might get around to getting the Bible on CD (which I think is around 60). Even at 128 that still ends up taking up some space.
Posted by: pgrzelak

Space, the final frontier... - 24/07/2003 09:28

Greetings!

Let's see...

how are you going to go from 160 gb --> 40 gb

I am not certain yet. I have a favorites playlist that I keep randomized for short trips. That only has about 2,000 tracks, so that should fit on the Pearl.

Most people that I've seen pegging out anything over 120 GB are either audiobook people or they are ripping at a very high bit rate.

Or both...

A more sane average of about 200kbps yields enough space for 1600 CDs.

Actually, that is about right.

I keep putting on full albums whether I like all the songs or not, just so I have them for whatever reason (which I probably wouldn't do on the Pearl).

Same here. Since the car player is docked at the office, I have the entire library here on demand and online.

You can never have too much space...
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Space, the final frontier... - 24/07/2003 12:15

I hear the "5GB is enough for anyone" argument all the time. I didn't think it would show up here, of all places.

I bought my Empeg for the main reason that I was tired of carrying a big case of CDs, only to find the one I wanted was at home. Hell, I had been dreaming of the ability to carry my entire music collection for years before I found the sweet, sweet empeg...

Now the technology to do that has shrunk to the handheld size, and I am more than ready. I currently have about ~50GB of Mp3s, mostly VBR, but I am still upgrading from 128k CBR. There is some pruning I can do, bootlegs and such I keep just for fun, but I waould really like to fit ALL my music PLUS a few Gigs free for work backups and usefull utilities.

This places my current minimum at about 60 GB. I could have that today with my Archos, but I am so eager to see what empeg has come up with I am willing to wait... a little... longer...

"You can never have too much Space"
AMEN!
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 13:51

Following this thread, all 27 pages (57 printed) of it, has been so heart-wrenching, it's moved me to register (even though I don't own an empeg car/Rio Car, in order to post my own ignominious (yet vainglorious) drivel!

I'll begin with a techno-dweeb follow-up question to a post from 10 weeks ago (how's that for 'netiquette?) mentioning that the Rio Karma will have an onboard USB host controller (implying that would allow for certain kinds of "expansion").

So will the onboard interface allow for file transfer directly to a connected USB slave device, say a USB mass storage device (doubling as a basic flash-memory MP3 player; you know what I'm getting at) *without* a PC involved at all?

You also haven't given details on the display, although it looks pretty nifty in RobV's pictures. One would assume it will support music-synchronized animations like the car unit?

OK, that was 2 questions. Already overstayed my welcome.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 14:18

So will the onboard interface allow for file transfer directly to a connected USB slave device, say a USB mass storage device (doubling as a basic flash-memory MP3 player; you know what I'm getting at) *without* a PC involved at all?
Although the hardware electronics in the Karma could (as described in that old thread) theoretically support something like that, it is not known whether or not the player firmware will be written to actually do it.

Keep in mind that, in order to do that, the player firmware would need drivers for the device in question and then the user interface would need to be written. I'm sure their hands are full just getting the thing working with a basic feature set right now.
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 14:32

>> did we get any kind of price range for the karma yet?

No, but I did make big whopping inferences from a couple of Rob's earlier posts: namely, that it's aimed at the high end users who appreciate things like fully parametric EQ, and that the sizes offered will both be "larger than the equivalent new iPod capacity." His use of the e-word made me think: $399 for a unit 1/3 bigger (20GB) than a 15GB iPod & $499 for the unit 1/3 bigger (40GB) than a 30GB iPod. Both with docks.

Can almost hear the sound of D&M marketing cringing audibly. Hey, I'm just making stuff up for my own edutainment.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 14:55

To throw gasoline on the flame, I'm going to ask this question...

If that were true (I'm not saying it is, and I'd be willing to bet that even D&M haven't made a final decision on prices yet anyway since the thing is still in development), what would you think of that pricing scheme?
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 24/07/2003 21:38

If that was the pricing scheme, it wouldn't be too bad, but then again it wouldn't make it the definite choice for me.

There's plenty of options out there, and unless the Rio Karma proves to be awesome in features (which I suspect that it will be), I might reconsider getting something that has been out a bit longer with possible dropping prices.

Then again I've never owned a Rio product (ahh don't ban me!), so I don't know firsthand the quality and capabilities of their products.

Just on another note, I don't think Creative Labs will put much competition out in the HDD player category soon at least. Creative in Asia now have the Creative Nomad Jukebox Zen NX, which is just a slight improvement over the original Zen. It's smaller and lighter, but not by that much (it can't compare to a new iPod). There aren't any noticeable major features added to it, except that it looks more sleek than the original (besides still being somewhat bulky). It comes in 20 and 30 GB capacities. Click here for more information! We do not know if it will be available in America, however, and my guess is that they won't design a different one for America (if they do release a newer design). It doesn't seem very special at all.
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 10:41

geez , that nomad ZEN NX has absolutely no style whatsoever.. my old Neo Jukebox looks more attractive than that thing. dunno what their thinking there..
If you had the choice of these 2 players, which one would you definately pick? not an easy decision..
1. New IPOD 15GB $350 - http://ipod.com/ipod
2. Karma 20GB $399 (not official price)
Dam, i want both!

brian
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 13:03

Karma.... hands down. The Jemplodish (take that IEspell!) software riding in the Karma sells me.

The thing is, at $399 is the Karma's software/physical dimensions going to sell me over the function and possibly inexpensive upgradeable nature of the RCA Lyra or the more expensive Archos AV300?

Inquiring minds want to know...
PS: Check out the 3D views of the Archos. The camera attachment is rather clever.
Posted by: booey

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 13:29

man, both those units look sweet. some Archos products have been known to be quite "glitchy" tho.. wonder if this unit is any better, and it is 600 bux.. too expensive for my blood.
I was even thinking about this unit, walmart sells them.
portable DVD/VCD player, and plays mp3's. Burn a few DVD's of mp3 and its not too bad for the money!
Initial 8-inch Portable DVD/VCD Player
Initial 7-inch Portable DVD/VCD Player
Initial 4.2 -inch Portable DVD/VCD Player




brian
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 15:25

You'd probably like a simple or on the "Are they worth it?"

Clearly, you don't know me very well (yet).

It all boils down to a four-letter word. You've got to do what the sleeker-looking iPods have done, and that is get people to say COOL when they see it. Or PHAT. Or whatever it is they say these days. Apple's done it, and it's daunting competition, especially if the Windows integration with iTunes & Music Store happens in time for U.S. Christmas shopping! Matching Apple on price with a bit higher capacity (but not an order of magnitude higher, since nobody needs that) isn't gonna cut it; you've got to offer something cooler or more compelling. The Karma's form factor will appeal to some; others will still prefer the PDA-like iPod. So that's a wash. One potentially compelling quality for the Rio will be transfer speed over 100MB Ethernet, which matters w/multi-GB devices (and most people don't have USB 2.0 yet, so deemphasizing USB 1.1 speed is appropriate). From what I've already read on this board, we can presume the software/firmware will be compelling and rock-solid. Hard to sell products like this on non-sexy qualities like reliability (i.e., it must be a computer product with CE-style indestructability), but obviously that'll be important long-term for reputation sake.

My advice if D&M Marketing is lurking (Ha!) is to really make the in-store packaging and display snazzy. Show that big blue display dancing to the music. (I've seen Best Buy displays of the Zen that made it look cool, and it's a boring brick.)

So, bottom line is that yes, I'd be willing to pay that, but I'm the niche market if ever there was one. I'd give anything to know what Apple's sales figures have been for the 15GB & 30GB iPods, as compared to the $299 10GB model w/o the dock. It would be bad news if it turns out that the consumer mass market just won't pay more than $300 for digital audio players, no matter how cool (or huge the capacity). Hope that's false, but this is the era of the $50 DVD player
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 15:41

Oh, now you dragging video into the equation? Then hold out for the HDD400, Philips upcoming video version of its 15GB HDD100 audio jukebox.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 15:43

I'd give anything to know what Apple's sales figures have been for the 15GB & 30GB iPods, as compared to the $299 10GB model w/o the dock.
Good point! I wonder if that info is publicly available somewhere?
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 15:44

Did notice the MuVo NX, which looks like a pretty [PunAlert] flashy [/PunAlert] upgrade to their mass-storage player.
Posted by: GO_MINI

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 16:45

I want to play around with a Karma.

Yours is available. Go out and do something really good, or really stupid, and then just wait for the result.
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 25/07/2003 19:28

Of people at work with new players (3 or 4 that I know of), no one has bought a 10GB. Only 15 and 30. I suspect they're all selling well.

My take on the other units mentioned here:

RCA - the thing is HUGE. It's RCA. The one bad review on Amazon likely tells the whole story. Negatory on this product. It also doesn't mention anything about video on any of the amazon specs.

Philips - pictures? No mention of video for this "multi-media" device. Too expensive for such low storage 15GB is next to useless for "multimedia" when music-only products like the iPod are selling with 30GB.

Archos - oh boy. Unless they pull a rabbit out of you know where.... Serious quality concerns with older products.

So what happened to all the other PVP devices? Including the one announced by SonicBlue? Did that stay with Rio after the buy?

The Karma must be substantially cheaper than the iPod to compete well. But not too low priced that it seems "cheap" Apple will not drop the price on their iPods when such a device comes out. They can *always* command a higher price than anyone else and will continue to do so because that price is part of their image. They must maintain a certain value associated with their products. There's still plenty of market for a music-only solution especially in these form factors.

I do want to see a palm-sized multi-media device with an attractive price and decent storage size, even if it's something dumb enough to play only video and music files as opposed to a device with full computer capabilities in a hand-held form-factor. But such a device has to allow for easy upgrades if it hopes to succeed. If it doesn't play DivX and a number of variants then it won't be nearly as attractive. It would be a great way to carry around programming recorded with PVRs such as the All-in-Wonder, etc.. Or of course ripped DVDs (your own of course).

Bruno
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/07/2003 10:06

Apple will not drop the price on their iPods when such a device comes out. They can *always* command a higher price than anyone else and will continue to do so because that price is part of their image

You must be kidding! Their margins must be extremely slim, at least on the 10GB model. I imagine they only make money because they sell a large amount of product direct via Apple stores and their web store. Of course their volume is also huge.


Rob
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/07/2003 11:14

Rob, I don't know what their margins are, but I can tell you that with everything else, Apple does not do low margins. I suspect they're building the iPods a lot cheaper than most people assume.

In any case, if their margins are indeed low, then there's another reason to back my claim that they will not drop their prices. I defnitely prefer what the Karma offers over the iPod, however once Apple establishes a market it's a tough proposition for anyone to come along and scoop them. Just forget about the Newton though.

Just imagine for a second someone wanting to come along and oust eBay. I think that's an extreme example, but along the same lines. And for the record, I don't even think Microsoft could take down the eBay machine, regardless of how much they spent.

Bruno
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/07/2003 14:11

I agree on the 10GB model. I think Apple's using the classic "loss leader" marketing technique; lure 'em with the sub-$300 model and then sell 'em on the benefits of 50% more "room to grow" and that handy dock. And Bruno's coworkers notwithstanding, when I go to my local Best Buy and CompUSA, they're always sold out of 10GB iPods....

BTW, I'm really rooting for the new (Denon & Marantz) Rios to be the iPods of the non-Mac world.
Posted by: time

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 26/07/2003 16:23

One would assume it will support music-synchronized animations like the car unit?

While these would be slick eye candy, they would most definitely come at the price of battery life, which in my HD-based-portable experience (the Riot mostly) is the premium commodity--even over disk space. My usage has the player in my pocket (not looking at fancy graphics) and hoping the tunes keep playing until I get to my next charging opportunity.

Here's hoping they crush the ipods!
- Tim
Posted by: johnmcd3

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 27/07/2003 01:36

Here's hoping they crush the ipods!
An excellent toast!
Posted by: oliver

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 27/07/2003 23:54

I just had a good idea, at least I think so. I'm sure you guys have already thought of it, but I figured I would still say something.

Will Denon offer a per-order page, for empeg-owners to get on a list, so we could really be one of the first mass groups to get our hands on them? By "per-order" I mean, just a que until you guys are done polishing up the UI, and squashing any remaining bugs. I’m even willing to pay for the unit right now, and just have it show up on my doorstep within say the next 6-8 weeks

I think it may, I hope, be some decent numbers for you guys to get another early insight in how many of your current customers, and the few people that have created accounts on the bbs just because of the hype of this product, would be willing to spend another $400+ to bring their music collection everywhere, at all times, while being on pretty much every waking moment of every day. Heck, maybe even while you sleep for some people.

Which brings me to my last idea, which I have mentioned before, I would love a lifetime counter. Which could tell me the crazy total number of time my empeg device has had power for. It would even be cooler if it would go into more detail, and list how many songs total played also.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 28/07/2003 22:19

Pre-ordering sounds like a cool idea, but only if they are sure of the date that they're going to release. I'm going to get sick of waiting after a pre-order not knowing how long it's going to take.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 00:23

By the way, is it possible to post more eye candy of the Karma?

I've drooled all over all the current ones already. Perhaps some nice angle shots of her nice body and such? Some highlights of upcoming features? I don't know, I just want to see more pictures of her.
Posted by: tonyc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 07:41

I've drooled all over all the current ones already. Perhaps some nice angle shots of her nice body and such? Some highlights of upcoming features? I don't know, I just want to see more pictures of her.
It's really funny you phrase it like that, because I noticed this weekend that the Karma is shown in a recent issue of Playboy magazine. I am not kidding about this. It's in one of their sections where they review gadgets and stuff. Sadly I think it was just a straight-on frontal view like the ones Rob has provided us with, and there were no details beyond what we already know.

And no, I normally don't read the articles, but I was trying to flip to one of the pictorials and the beauty and splendor of the Karma drew me in.
Posted by: JeffS

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 08:26

I noticed this weekend that the Karma is shown in a recent issue of Playboy magazine . . . And no, I normally don't read the articles, but I was trying to flip to one of the pictorials and the beauty and splendor of the Karma drew me in.
That should earn you at least a few geek points.
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 09:31

Yes, but they're cancelled out by the machismo points of having a copy of Playboy to begin with.
-Zeke
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 13:14

Does anyone have a scan of the advertisement? I've seen the picture from the advertisements (it's online) but I have not seen the actual entire advertisement.
Posted by: hybrid8

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 14:28

How about a picture of someone with one in their hand?

Bruno
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 15:24

How about a picture of someone with one in their hand?
Well, that could be a problem, depending on who's holding it.
Posted by: Taym

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 16:37

Tony, I am having problems in viewing anything on http://www.geekhackfilk.com/... I get "the page cannot be displayed " 3 out of 4 times, and it is anyway very slow. Any problem with your ISP? Just curious, and hoping this helps other people who are trying to see all the pics of the euromeet 2003...
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 16:42

I've not had any trouble all day. Do some traceroutes and see if some of them are dying at a certain routing point.

The administrator of that server is Ricin from the BBS here, so perhaps he can chime in.
Posted by: tman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 16:50

I can't even resolve www.geekhackfilk.com. I thought it might be some problem in a transatlantic link but it also doesn't work on our colocated server in the US.

Your two DNS servers are listed as ns1.pbp.net and ns1.pbp.net. They both don't respond for some reason?

ns1.pbp.net:
22 dsl081-049-190.sfo1.dsl.speakeasy.net (64.81.49.190) 83.703 ms 84.701 ms 83.034 ms
23 * * *

ns2.pbp.net
9 209-101-80-2.lad-c000.cust.gw.epoch.net (209.101.80.2) 68.474 ms 69.121 ms 68.481 ms
10 * * *
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 17:03

dig geekhackfilk.com

; <<>> DiG 9.1.1 <<>> geekhackfilk.com
;; global options: printcmd
;; Got answer:
;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUERY, status: NOERROR, id: 25316
;; flags: qr rd ra; QUERY: 1, ANSWER: 1, AUTHORITY: 2, ADDITIONAL: 2

;; QUESTION SECTION:
;geekhackfilk.com. IN A

;; ANSWER SECTION:
geekhackfilk.com. 81802 IN A 66.92.222.44

;; AUTHORITY SECTION:
geekhackfilk.com. 168202 IN NS ns1.pbp.net.
geekhackfilk.com. 168202 IN NS ns2.pbp.net.

;; ADDITIONAL SECTION:
ns1.pbp.net. 76346 IN A 66.92.222.35
ns2.pbp.net. 76346 IN A 66.81.103.69

;; Query time: 15 msec
;; SERVER: 127.0.0.1#53(127.0.0.1)
;; WHEN: Tue Jul 29 19:51:40 2003
;; MSG SIZE rcvd: 125


No problems resolving...

telnet geekhackfilk.com 80
Trying 66.92.222.44...
Connected to geekhackfilk.com.
Escape character is '^]'.
GET /gallery/ HTTP/1.1
Host: geekhackfilk.com

HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Date: Wed, 30 Jul 2003 00:02:10 GMT
Server: Apache/1.3.27 (Unix) (Gentoo/Linux)
Set-Cookie: PHPSESSID=822ab1ca2080a5f20ecd6c5500b3be65; path=/
Expires: Thu, 19 Nov 1981 08:52:00 GMT
Cache-Control: no-store, no-cache, must-revalidate, post-check=0, pre-check=0
Pragma: no-cache
Transfer-Encoding: chunked
Content-Type: text/html

210c
<html>
<head>
<title>Tony's Photo Galleries</title>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="http://www.geekhackfilk.com/gallery/css/embedded_style.css.default">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="http://www.geekhackfilk.com/gallery/css/standalone_style.css.default"> </head>
<body>

<table width=100% border=0>
<tr>
<td>
<span class="head">
Tony's Photo Galleries </span>
</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td valign="top">

<table width=100% border=0 cellspacing=0>
<tr><form action="http://www.geekhackfilk.com/gallery/search.php" >
<input type=hidden name="" value="">
<td valign="middle" align="right">
<span class="admin"> Search: </span>
<input style="font-size=10px;" type="text" name="searchstring" value="" size="25">
</td>
</form>
</tr>
<tr><td height=2><img src=http://www.geekhackfilk.com/gallery/images/pixel_trans.gif></td></tr></table>
<!-- admin section begin -->
...
...
...


All looks good from comcast.net
Posted by: tman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 17:14

Hmm. Seems to work now. I couldn't connect at all to ns?.pbp.net earlier.
Posted by: ricin

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 18:12

ns1 is pingable, but won't show up in the traceroute.

There haven't been any problems with either ns today.
Posted by: tman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 18:17

Yeah. I noticed that you can't do a traceroute to them once they started working again for me.
It would just time out and not give me any response. Very strange. It's still working as well.
Posted by: bootsy

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 20:00

I can't see it from work... and we don't block anything.

Hmmm... Odd, I can see it from my home machine. I don't know what that means, but I thought I'd let you know.
Posted by: tfabris

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 21:59

It's a fairly new domain name. Perhaps some domain name servers are slow to propogate?

Either that, or it's the internet gnomes at work again.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 29/07/2003 22:13

If you give one to me I have normal sized hands, I'll take pictures! AHH GIVE ME ONE NOW!

Hmm the models that you guys are testing (at least from the previously posted pictures) say "Made in Malaysia". Any possibility I could go to a factory in Malaysia and get my hands on one?
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 09:04

No, because I'm there at the moment and will procure a big stick to keep bounty hunters away

Hugo (yawn, jetlag, etc)
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 10:01

Take some video of Karmas being made so we can watch it at the next Euro meet.
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 11:56

Well, assuming Hugo's there to do the primary inspection of the first units off the line, throw in two weeks to finish the production, four to five for ocean shipment to California, a few more to fill the distribution channels, it looks like we're at the end of September at least.

Prove me wrong, PLEASE!

-Zeke
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 12:32

Enjoying the afternoon rain?

Are you in/near KL? If so, and you get some free time, here's some places you may enjoy;

Hard Rock Cafe. It's likely to be the cheapest HRC you ever go to.

KL Tower - Great views. The Petronas Towers usually have a long line, and you can't go to the top anyway - only as far as the bridge.

Baku Caves. About 20 minutes by dirt cheap cab North of KL, huge cave in a big rock with a temple in the middle. Lots of steps to climb, so best in the morning before the humidity gets too oppressive. Lots of roaming monkeys.

China Town. Has to be seen to be believed. Cheap knock-offs are everywhere.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 14:40

He's actually there? I thought I was joking (or are you joking?).

Anyway, just an update on coming competition since this thread is basically a general portable player thread. I am not trying to promote anything, but Toshiba (Japan) is right now having one of those mysterious websites that'll be updated every so often with new info. of a new HDD player. Click here! They say it'll be less than 13 mm in height (I assume depth), so that it will actually be thinner than the new iPod. That is pretty impressive. The other numbers will be revealed by the dates shown there.

I just hope 500 doesn't mean something dumb like 500 folders max haha. Anyway, I know most of you will still trust the Empeg team with innovation in the Rio products, and I do not plan to try to convince you otherwise. I am just showing you what's coming soon too. Toshiba, nevertheless, released a crappy HDD player before, and history might repeat itself. At least it'll be thin.
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 15:55

I'm actually in Penang, yes. I don't think I'll be getting much time for sightseeing though, but thanks for the suggestions genixia.

13mm is pretty darn slim, and only really achievable if you use the toshiba drives (which we don't). 500=500 minutes playtime (8 and a bit hours, like the iPod?) possibly. 10 is obviously 10GB.

Hugo
Posted by: altman

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 15:56

Only time can prove you wrong.

Hugo
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 17:18

big, fat,

-Zeke
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 17:47

Hmm that could be a possibility.

I think I read somewhere that the iPod's battery life is pretty short because they had to use a small battery to get it to a slimmer size. That may apply to the Toshiba model as well.

The iHP-100 uses a Lithium-Polymer battery and they rate the battery life at 16 hours, but at the cost of thickness.
Posted by: genixia

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 18:58

That sounds reasonable. I doubt that they've pulled off a technological coup and that it's really 500GB and 10hours. They obviously haven't decided on the price yet. "?"

I've heard that the beaches are nice in Penang - I unfortunately didn't get a chance to find out for myself, but some of my friends assure me that they are certainly better than the average UK beach.
Posted by: cmcdonald

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 31/07/2003 19:15

Anything's better than the average UK beach
Posted by: Mach

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 02:40

Awww yeah.....anyone on that side of the world want to call J&R when they open and see what the deal is?

J&R Music World - $499.98

Rio Karma 40GB Digital Audio Jukebox - Like the iPod and Zen, the Rio Karma crams a jaw-dropping 40GB of space in an extremely portable frame - allowing you to take thousands of songs with you wherever you go! But Rio has put their own stamp on the jukebox genre with cool features, like the included docking station. The docking station has Dual RCA Line-Outs, an Ethernet Port, and auto-synchronization with your PC. Great for sharing Music on a Network or playing over speakers for everyone to enjoy. And that's not all...
Dynamic Playlist Generation
Auto-DJ - intelligently finds, mixes and creates playlists from tracks on command
Support for MP3, WMA, and the increasingly popular Ogg Vorbis digital formats
Up to 15 hours of playback with the built-in rechargeable Lithium-Ion battery
5-band parametric Equalizer with presets
USB 2.0 interface
Includes: Sennheiser MX300 earbuds, USB 2.0 cable, Stereo RCA cable, Ethernet cable, AC power supply, & manual



Posted by: Mach

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 04:39

Just to stir the pot further...

http://s1.amazon.com/exec/varzea/preorder/new/B0000AQIG0/ref=oor_dp_e_re/002-1874561-7234448

Amazon shows the 40GB at $443.99 but not shipping or correctly listed at this point.

Posted by: puckalicious

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 04:49

DROOOLL!!!!
MUST HAVE!!
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 06:20

bought it
Posted by: eliceo

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 08:39

which one did you buy from? Anything with free shipping and no tax to California would be good for me. Estimated shipping date huh?
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 08:44

J and R has free shipping and tax is only charged in NY.
Posted by: eliceo

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 09:05

aw man thats so tempting, must resist until i have an idea of shipping date.
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 09:17

Hmm... They took the J&R link down. It was working before... Did they get yelled at?
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 09:18

Ha. I got my order in.
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 09:25

That's nice... : )

[text smiley intentional]

My main problem is, even with a 40, deciding what stuff to load on it. The playlist I normally keep randomized for short trips is about 10GB, so that is easy. But what else to select...
Posted by: Roger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 09:46

But what else to select...

You'll be able to relax and let Rio Music Manager 2 make that decision for you.
Posted by: mcomb

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 10:50

But what else to select...

What I do with my 10Gig iPod is have two smart playlists. One of these selects 2Gigs of my most recently added music. The other selects 7Gigs of my most often played music. Both are automatically synced to the iPod whenever I plug it in. The spare gig (600Megs actually) is used for spur of the moment stuff I decide I want to listen to and file taxi purposes. Although this isn't as good as having everything I own always available it does a great job of keeping me from ever having to worry about what to put on the iPod.

From Roger's comment it sounds like their Music Manager tool will allow you to do something similar.

-Mike
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 11:00

True, but my collection has outpaced my local hard drive space. It looks like I will have to upgrade my PC's hard drive to keep everything local for RMM2 to do its job! As long as that 40GB sync is pretty quick...
Posted by: mcomb

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 11:04

True, but my collection has outpaced my local hard drive space.

Your collection seems to be rapidly outpacing North America's local hard drive space
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 11:07

Nah, not really. Just that my hard drive is older, it is a small Shuttle case, I really don't want to upgrade, and my music partition is too small for all the data. I still have about 20GB to kick around, so I should be okay for a little while on the player.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 12:51

What are the other three things doing in that picture?!
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 12:53

The three other things are new flash players. I can only remember the name of one of them. Chiba.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 12:56

Oh okay. I would have went crazy for that yellow one since I love the color yellow, but I'd rather have a HDD player.
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 12:59

I think that one is Cali. Chiba is the axe blade-looking one. I can't rember the name of the MuVo-style one. 'Flashy' maybe?

EDIT: The empeg guys claim to not be responsible for coming up with those names. Uh huh.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 12:59

Oh, and there seems to be a ton of them coming. Chiba, Fuse, Nitrus, Cali, and Eigen. Chiba is 128 MB/256 MB, Fuse is in 128 MB, Nitrus and Eigen are 1.5 GB models, and the Cali seems to be a sport model available in 128 MB/256 MB. A site concerning the Nitrus/Eigen

Wow I find it really cool that they are releasing their whole new line of digital audio players at once. It's like a bomb.
Posted by: robricc

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 13:02

That's it! Fuse is the muvo-style one.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 13:07

Seems like we're chatting to each other. Hehe.
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 14:01

And everyone is wondering why the folks @ empeg are too busy to get a beta of 3.0 ready for the car player...
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 14:09

Yeah, how DARE they say it's a Digitalway product (the guys who make those cheapo MPIO flash players)? Probably don't have "Digital Networks North America" in their database yet....
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 14:23

So, to recap for a left-right challenged geek like me, from the top and proceeding clockwise, we have:
1. Karma (40GB HDD)
2. Chiba
3. Fuse
4. Cali.

And actually not pictured at all are the new, 1.5GB Cornice SE based units, the Nitrus Urban or Eigen Executive?

Do we have confirmation from Cambridge?
Posted by: Waterman981

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 15:09

Did I miss this before, so Karma will have PC-syncronization.... Sweet!!! Hrmm.... maybe one day for our Empegs too!
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 15:42

Wow I find it really cool that they are releasing their whole new line of digital audio players at once

Yeah and you wonder why V3 is taking a while

Rob
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 15:43

And everyone is wondering why the folks @ empeg are too busy to get a beta of 3.0 ready for the car player.

OK Rob, read the rest of the thread before responding.. doh..
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 16:07

Remember, Sleep is a "Good Thing"...
Posted by: Waterman981

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 18:17

I just saw a new VW commercial. Thought ya'll might be interested.
Posted by: msandrews

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 19:51

Rob what stores in the U.S. wil carry the Karma?
Best Buy, Circuit City, Good Guys.....?

I guess Im wondering who I should call up first!
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 20:34

How about the Rio website or are they not going to sell it ?
Posted by: ninti

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 22:12

> How about the Rio website or are they not going to sell it ?

You REALLY don't want to buy it directly from Rio. Their direct sales people have their heads firmly implanted up...well, you know. Trust me, pay more if you have to, but avoid buying from them direct.
Posted by: thrasher

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 22:14

I have had nothing but great service buying striaght thru sonic blue.
Posted by: ninti

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 22:16

Maybe you were lucky. Go back and read some of the horror stories from the Empeg firesale.
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 01/08/2003 22:45

Yeah I know about their bad reputation but I did'nt have a problem when I ordered my rio central.
Posted by: mtempsch

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 02/08/2003 00:20

new VW commercial

Cassette adapter, wires all over the place - ick!

/Michael
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 02/08/2003 03:49

Go back and read some of the horror stories from the Empeg firesale.

That was a different company, and in any case it was out sourced in those days. If you haven't noticed, things like the Rio website, support site, customer care and so forth have suddenly got rather good!

Rob
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 02/08/2003 11:51

And don't forget the orange-squeezer-jammed-into-the-cupholder car mount for the little bugger. That's elegant!
Posted by: ninti

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 02/08/2003 13:03

In reply to:

If you haven't noticed, things like the Rio website, support site, customer care and so forth have suddenly got rather good!



Oh, I hadn't noticed, because the only Rio thing I have is the Empeg. Ok cool, I'll take your word that they have changed though. Never mind.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 02/08/2003 20:55

This might be a dumb question but..

Is the battery in the Karma removable? And how long do you think the unit will last before the battery dies? (like dies, not runs out of juice, but dies)
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/08/2003 03:47

I think modern batteries last 500 charges before they stop holding their charge. Thats if you look after them well.

I'd also guess that you would be able to replace them easy enough.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 03/08/2003 21:11

Thanks, and bump. So how long will it be till they're released? Or were Amazon and J&R just putting them up way too early?
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 03:24

No definite date, but its been hinted at September/October-ish. (If I've interpreted the clues correctly!)
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 08:44

not sure there's anything new here, but I thought I'd post it:

http://www.gizmodo.com/archives/007993.php#007993
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 12:40

Nope, nothing new, but I like seeing other sites report on it.

They forgot the Eigen and Nitrus though.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 12:44

This might not be important but I just realized that the retail prices for these quite possibly can be $500 for the 40 GB and $400 for the 20 GB. Amazon usually sells new products for somewhat cheaper I guess to take in all the competition first (since they are one of the largest online stores anyway). It was $500 at J&R for the 40 GB one, so yeah, that's probably it.

Hmm I hope Amazon gets the 20 GB one also and sells it for cheaper on release, because I do not know if I would need that much.

Oh the 20 GB version is coming out first anyway. Amazon might as well those off because I'm starting to drool too much.
Posted by: DLF

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 15:36

Interesting that Amazon has dummy pages up for almost all of Rio's new stuff (even incl. Eigen & Nitrus!):

Amazon.com link

The sole exception: Rio Karma 20GB. I'll bet the real page for it is imminent.

edit - Trimmed URL down to avoid scrolling the thread - Drakino
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 15:56

Er yeah, that's how I found out the names, I guess I forgot to mention that here.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 15:58

Can we get some boxshots? Boxes are cool. Hehe.
Posted by: mschrag

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 19:33

Gizmodo is now linking to the Empeg BBS for a picture of the Karma ... Rob asked early on in this thread that we not send out links to pictures that appear here. I know it's getting closer to release, but I assume this request still stands. Please everyone try to respect his request or I'm sure it will get tougher for him to convince Rio that it's OK to put early access information/pictures here for us to gawk at.

ms
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 20:20

I think that that picture is okay since it does not look like it comes from the developers themselves (or does it?)

The pictures that I think they mean not to send out are the ones when it was still in development, the ones where it showed the player inside the dock, and a Coke can compared to the dock and player.
Posted by: msaeger

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 20:22

I'm with you.

I would hope that the gizmodo place found this thread on their own and someone from here didn't send them the link. I'm sure gizmodo doesn't give a crap about Rob asking not to link the pictures they just want to post their stupid little blurb.

Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 04/08/2003 20:23

Yep.

Please don't repost those pics anywhere else. I got special permission to post them to the empeg BBS.


I think the keyword in that sentence from Rob is "those", meaning only the pictures that he posted at the time of writing.
Posted by: Mach

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 00:39

The pics that I posted were from J&R website before they pulled the page down. Unless Rob or J&R takes exception, I don't see a problem.
Posted by: rob

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 06:10

Unfortunately the point at which BBS threads start getting linked from larger sites is the point at which I'll have to stop talking about grey area things, i.e. stuff which is not quite public but not restricted either. This is a good place to try out ideas and get reactions from a small group of people, but I don't want to see myself quoted in places where the "off the record" aspect may not be fully understood.

If we stick to talking about the car player then nobody else will care enough to pay attention

Rob
Posted by: rmitz

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 07:16

Hmm, guess I'm screwed for my end-of-August birthday, eh?
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 08:55

Question:

Is there a way that the anonymous user features of the BBS can be disabled until after said (undated) release? It still would not deal with anyone signing up on the BBS only for data, but it would cut off the random seekers.
Posted by: Mach

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 13:14

Spurred on by your chutzpah in trying to pre-order from J&R, I did the same thing with the amazon link. Now, you can no longer find the Karma by searching but the link now shows the price at $499.99 instead of the $443.99.

I took the liberty of adding a review while I was there .
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Best Portable player right now? - 05/08/2003 13:58

Doh.

They still have the Cali and Eigen listed on there as of 2:00 PM PST heh.
Posted by: Diznario

10,000+ page views and growing - 05/08/2003 16:56

Anyone else notice how many page views this thread has?

Outside linking or not, looks like the Karma is pretty damn popular.

I hope this is a sign of things to come. Good job guys, it looks awesome!
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: 10,000+ page views and growing - 05/08/2003 17:20

I'm a regular page view adder. :P
Posted by: PeterDLai

UPDATED: Toshiba G20SS Concept HDD Player - 05/08/2003 22:36

Click here for the updated page!

The 500 means 500 CDs; they're probably trying to impress the majority of music listeners who might not know what a "gigabyte" or whatever is. They assumed a low 10 songs per CD, meaning 5000 songs. If each song is about 4 MB, that'll be 20,000 MB, or about 20 GB (I think that's what it says, I don't read Japanese or anything though).

Makes sense though, G20SS.

If you also look in the background of the 13 and 500 pages, you'll see a slim preview of the player. The screen seems a little small, but eh.

The next date is 8/12 for the number: 10. 10 hour battery life? Perhaps. Who knows.

So far though it doesn't seem to be that impressive except in slimness.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Silence! - 06/08/2003 15:23

Hmm, should we start a new thread just for the Karma? This topic seems too vague, unless everyone's mindset is that the Karma IS the best portable player haha. Besides, this is getting really long.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Silence! - 06/08/2003 19:34

Why is it so quiet? AHH.
Posted by: DLF

Re: Silence! - 07/08/2003 09:34

Because apparently you missed the other thread, in which setting up a dedicated Karma discussion was considered and rejected. And to keep the external linking to this thread to a minimum, General >> General is now hidden until login. So until an official announcement, I think that's it. zzzzz
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Silence! - 07/08/2003 23:52

Er but that doesn't mean we can't talk in here, right?
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Silence! - 08/08/2003 02:00

Its been discussed - you gotta have SOME suprise when you get one! Soon enough... soon enough. Patience.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Silence! - 08/08/2003 14:49

Okay well someone already posted some of the features it's going to have.

Oh well, it's been fun in this thread, later guys hehe.
Posted by: DLF

Re: Silence! - 08/08/2003 15:43

OK, OK.

Go back and take a look at a handful of updates to Amazon's page.
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 00:04

WOOT!
Posted by: pgrzelak

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 04:17

Interesting! Following the link up to other DNNA products lists thie Chiba 256 as "Available for pre-order" and "This item will be released on August 21, 2003." Since the smaller Chiba doesn't have a date / time stamp, I do not know if Amazon is serious or not...

I wonder who the one reviewer for the 40GB Karma was... (no, not me)
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 04:19

I think it was Jerz.
Posted by: Jerz

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 05:35

Nope, not me... I believe it was Mach.
Posted by: CrackersMcCheese

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 05:45

Thats the guy. Sorry!
Posted by: PeterDLai

Re: Silence! - 10/08/2003 16:34

Another thing that is interesting is that Amazon lists the Rio Karma's battery life as 20 hours?

And they changed the Amazon.com price back to $444. Ahh Amazon stop doing stuff! Either get it right or take it off!