Originally Posted By: Archeon
The reason was I'm using a geothermal heat pump to heat my house.

Right, the answer is different for people with heat pumps, because they're less efficient at higher outputs. This is not the case for any other type of heating: electric, gas, coal, oil etc. -- in those cases, consider the energy flow across the boundary of your house to get the correct answer that turning down the thermostat is a win.

Peter