Unoffical empeg BBS

Quick Links: Empeg FAQ | RioCar.Org | Hijack | BigDisk Builder | jEmplode | emphatic
Repairs: Repairs

Topic Options
#210472 - 23/03/2004 22:59 Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next letter
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
I would like to suggest that while in the playlist menu, the left and right buttons could be available to go to the next or previous letters in the alphabet. The remote lets you do a similar process, but I do not use the remote much.

The biggest reason for this is that I have my playlists done by artists, and I've got a lot of CDs Thanks!
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210473 - 24/03/2004 00:25 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next letter [Re: liquidiq]
tfabris
carpal tunnel

Registered: 20/12/1999
Posts: 31563
Loc: Seattle, WA
Do you have a proposed scheme whereby Hijack could actually accomplish this? Remember that Hijack is not the player software. It can do some tricks by screen-scraping, but for the most part, it has no idea what the player software is doing. For example, I don't see how it can easily know what the next letter of the alphabet would be.

Have you ever tried spinning the wheel when you're in the playlists menu? It lets you go a lot faster.
_________________________
Tony Fabris

Top
#210474 - 24/03/2004 00:51 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: tfabris]
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
Yes, and I find spinning the wheel somewhat unreliable, as sometimes it goes backwards if I spin it too fast or other erratic behavoir.

I was just tossing out an idea, I do not know the inner workings of the code.
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210475 - 24/03/2004 01:03 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
TheTwin314
journeyman

Registered: 15/01/2002
Posts: 55
Loc: Kansas
I too agree that it would be a nice feature, no matter how it has to get done (hijack, player code update). And as to the spinning wheel, I find it has gotten more and more eratic. This weekend when I was testing out the new 8's I put in my car, a slight bump of the knob would turn the volume to full blast nearly blowing my speakers, and turning it back down was a much slower process. and I too have had the problem of it going backwards, seems to be a bit of a timing issue with the knob itself.

and in very large playlists, even spinning the wheel can take a long while, and in traffic, not a good idea as you must constantly look down to see where you are at, since if you click the wheel 5 times to the right, you could have skipped 5 entries, or 100, or -15, you never know, it'd be fun for a game, but not when you're trying to find a song . Whereas skipping the letter you could easily count out where you are at in the playlist.

so if not hijack, the player code could definitely use this feature.
_________________________
Empeg 50gig MkIIa (stolen :'(, my baby) In an Impreza 2.5 RS-T -also (new additions to the family)- Empeg 10gig MkIIa Empeg 50gig MkIIa

Top
#210476 - 24/03/2004 09:58 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next letter [Re: tfabris]
tonyc
carpal tunnel

Registered: 27/06/1999
Posts: 7058
Loc: Pittsburgh, PA
I don't see how it can easily know what the next letter of the alphabet would be.
True, but it might be possible for a user application to let the user scroll through the letters themselves, I dunno, using the knob maybe... And said application could inject the corresponding IR code for that letter when it's selected. It wouldn't be strictly "next letter / previous letter" but might be even more useful, as you could go from the A's to the Q's faster, without having to go through the B's, C's, etc.

liquidiq & TheTwin314, would this be an acceptable alternative for you guys?
_________________________
- Tony C
my empeg stuff

Top
#210477 - 24/03/2004 11:35 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: tonyc]
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
It would be better I think, but I still think my original idea is more useful for driving situations where you can think in your head what letter you are on

For example, you could do a button press for 2 seconds could mean next letter, and then a quick click just means next playlist entry. That would be the best situation I think.
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210478 - 24/03/2004 11:43 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
tfabris
carpal tunnel

Registered: 20/12/1999
Posts: 31563
Loc: Seattle, WA
That would be the best situation I think.
And if my grandmother had wheels she's be a wagon. Our point is that there's no easy way for Hijack to be able to do what you describe. Ynot's suggestion was the only work around he could think of.

Now, asking for the feature you describe in the player software instead of in Hijack is a much more realistic thing. However, the player software isn't in active development any more and the odds of a feature like that getting into 3.0 are slim.
_________________________
Tony Fabris

Top
#210479 - 24/03/2004 11:52 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: tfabris]
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
You've been such a great help, I appreciate it! My grandma has wheels, but it's a sedan, not a wagon.

Instead of bashing me for choosing the wrong software to put it in, where should I post for this to be added to the player software? I think other people would like to see it in there as well, it seems like a good feature to me.
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210480 - 24/03/2004 11:59 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
TheTwin314
journeyman

Registered: 15/01/2002
Posts: 55
Loc: Kansas
ha ha ha,.

you posted it in the right section, just shouldn't have mentioned hijack feature request in the title.

If they aren't going to actively develop the player software anymore........ they should open source it I know I know, they can't because they use a lot of it for newer products, but jeez...... we're a hungry bunch.
_________________________
Empeg 50gig MkIIa (stolen :'(, my baby) In an Impreza 2.5 RS-T -also (new additions to the family)- Empeg 10gig MkIIa Empeg 50gig MkIIa

Top
#210481 - 24/03/2004 12:05 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
wfaulk
carpal tunnel

Registered: 25/12/2000
Posts: 16706
Loc: Raleigh, NC US
_________________________
Bitt Faulk

Top
#210482 - 24/03/2004 12:23 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
tonyc
carpal tunnel

Registered: 27/06/1999
Posts: 7058
Loc: Pittsburgh, PA
For example, you could do a button press for 2 seconds could mean next letter, and then a quick click just means next playlist entry. That would be the best situation I think.
So if you want to skip to the letter 'K' you'd need to do ten separate long presses? 20 seconds to select a letter? Even if the long press delay is 1 second or 1/2 a second, that doesn't seem very useful. Even if it was done so that you could hold down the long press and it "repeated" the "next letter" command each time, it'd still take a long time, and you'd have to look down to see which letter you're picking (or count beeps or whatever.) *Maybe* if a knob press was used to switch from playlist to letter select mode it'd be usable, but that's about the only way I can think of it working in such a way that the left/right buttons do most of the work.

IMHO, the only reasonable way to do something like this (and one that leaves Mark I users out in the cold, unfortunately) would be to use the left/right for one function (individual playlist selection) and the knob for the other (changing letters). Those could be reversed, possibly.... But if you try to overload the left/right buttons for both letter and individual playlist selection, I think it becomes more of a hassle than it's worth.

I'm not trying to poo-poo your idea, but as the most likely person to try to implement something like this, I really have to question what the best way of doing it is.
_________________________
- Tony C
my empeg stuff

Top
#210483 - 24/03/2004 13:00 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
tfabris
carpal tunnel

Registered: 20/12/1999
Posts: 31563
Loc: Seattle, WA
Sorry, didn't mean to bash, was just trying to be funny. I wanted to clarify that the behavior you were requesting couldn't happen in Hijack.

Sometimes I forget to smiley-caption the tongue-in-cheek posts. Sorry about that.
_________________________
Tony Fabris

Top
#210484 - 24/03/2004 14:20 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: tonyc]
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
Yea, I see what you are saying now. I think using the knob for switching the letters would work out better, that way you can use the buttons for more precise playlist selection. Yea, now that I think about it, that would work a lot better

tfabris, it's cool, hehe.
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210485 - 24/03/2004 16:18 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: tfabris]
mlord
carpal tunnel

Registered: 29/08/2000
Posts: 14472
Loc: Canada
*Anything* can happen in Hijack. But some things are easier and more likely to happen than other things..

Top
#210486 - 24/03/2004 16:20 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: mlord]
cmtempeg
journeyman

Registered: 29/07/2003
Posts: 66
Loc: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

*Anything* can happen in Hijack

*ponders KDE running on his empeg*
_________________________
Hello, my name is Bingo. I like to climb on things. Can I have a banana? eek eek.

Top
#210487 - 25/03/2004 02:04 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: mlord]
andy
carpal tunnel

Registered: 10/06/1999
Posts: 5914
Loc: Wivenhoe, Essex, UK
*Anything* can happen in Hijack.

Can I have time travel included then please Mark
_________________________
Remind me to change my signature to something more interesting someday

Top
#210488 - 25/03/2004 04:58 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: cmtempeg]
peter
carpal tunnel

Registered: 13/07/2000
Posts: 4172
Loc: Cambridge, England
ponders KDE running on his empeg
Assuming that KDE is in ARM Debian, it should work out of the box on the Empeg, although there's no X (or fb) driver for the screen, so you could only use it on remote X displays (or Xvnc).

Peter

Top
#210489 - 25/03/2004 09:35 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: peter]
wfaulk
carpal tunnel

Registered: 25/12/2000
Posts: 16706
Loc: Raleigh, NC US
Or Xvfb.
_________________________
Bitt Faulk

Top
#210490 - 25/03/2004 12:18 Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right next le [Re: liquidiq]
rbenech
journeyman

Registered: 08/08/2001
Posts: 51
Loc: CA, USA
First off...
In reply to:

The remote lets you do a similar process, but I do not use the remote much.



Do you mean that pressing a number (i.e. 2 = ABC) will jump to that letter in the playlist? I didn't realize that is how it worked... I must try...

You could always set up your Playlists/Artists/Whatever into groups using jEmplode's Soup view. You can have it automatically put all the artists starting with A in the A folder, etc... Or you could group the letters to give you a better drill down speed. This is how I do it now.


\Playlists
\By Artist
\A-E
\Astral Projection
\F-J
....
\By Genre
\Ambient
...

\Playlist1
\Playlist2


P.S. Nice car ;-)
_________________________
Ryan here... Empeg [08000462] 40 Gig with Subaru WRX sport wagon attached... (still! pending memory + LED upgrade, sheesh, I've been sitting on my ass for years)

Top
#210491 - 25/03/2004 12:27 FAQ'd Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right [Re: TheTwin314]
rbenech
journeyman

Registered: 08/08/2001
Posts: 51
Loc: CA, USA
...and turning [the wheel] back down was a much slower process. and I too have had the problem of it going backwards, seems to be a bit of a timing issue with the knob itself.


Maybe
My Mk2's volume knob is being jumpy!
would be helpful...
_________________________
Ryan here... Empeg [08000462] 40 Gig with Subaru WRX sport wagon attached... (still! pending memory + LED upgrade, sheesh, I've been sitting on my ass for years)

Top
#210492 - 25/03/2004 15:05 FAQ'd Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right [Re: rbenech]
liquidiq
new poster

Registered: 16/01/2002
Posts: 12
Loc: Austin, TX
I've thought about doing a grouping of letters, but at the same time, I like to scroll through all the artists just to see what pops out at me instead of looking for something in particular.

I'm picky I know.

I'm am in no way that good at electronics to attempt the knob fix hahahaa
_________________________
- Steve
MKIIa 60GB in my '08 Mazda Miata PRHT

Top
#210493 - 26/03/2004 03:03 FAQ'd Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right [Re: liquidiq]
Roger
carpal tunnel

Registered: 18/01/2000
Posts: 5680
Loc: London, UK
but at the same time

You could set it up so that you can do either:

Playlists/All Artists
Playlists/Artists by Letter/A
Playlists/Artists by Letter/B

...etc...
_________________________
-- roger

Top
#210494 - 31/03/2004 04:29 FAQ'd Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right [Re: Roger]
rtundo
addict

Registered: 27/02/2001
Posts: 569
Loc: Albany, NY
I remember someone once requesting that we be able to rename hijack fake buttons.
For example: if you could rename button 2 on the remote to "ABC" button 3 "DEF" etc. then you could set up a popup menu that navigates the alphabet without the remote.

Top
#210495 - 13/05/2004 13:13 FAQ'd Re: Feature Request for Hijack: Left/Right [Re: liquidiq]
sirmanson
journeyman

Registered: 06/03/2002
Posts: 70
Loc: Tucson, AZ USA
You don't have to do the knob fix yourself. Click the Eutronix link at the top of the forums. They will do you right.
_________________________
----- RioCar 60gb

Top