I'm not sure how this couldn't set a precedent. "We want this now, but don't worry, we won't ask for it again."

Besides, aren't there still other avenues they can try? I thought I saw one report that Apple could increase the guy's iCloud storage limit, which might start the backups going again. I don't think I'd have a problem with that. I assume I don't understand that situation properly though.
_________________________
Matt