Why is it people get upset and dislike a movie because it didn't follow the source material? Almost every direct book->movie adaptation is horrible. I'd much rather see them start with an idea off a book, then come up with something more appropriate for the movie. A similar example is the SpiderMan critics who complain the movies had no comic counterparts, but used pieces from them, Well, do you want to go to a movie and see new things, and possibly be suprised? Or walk in knowing the basic story by heart?