Oooo, this is a good thread. I particularly like your requirements:
Quote:
which tracks still send a shiver down your spine when you hear them

I've been meaining to make a little mix CD of just those types of songs. Songs that are best listened to with giant can-style headphones, in a big comfy chair, in a pitch-black room. Too bad I can't remember any off the top of my head, but I've got them.

For now, I'll just throw out my favorite:

"Praying Ground"
on Scraps at Midnight
by Mark Lanegan

Okay, so I'm a little biased. He's my favorite artist of all time, but this song gets me for some reason, and I love listening to it in the exact manner I described above.
_________________________
Matt