I don't think it's a compass star, my memory seems to be that it was four-pointed stars, stretched vertically.
The stars might have had frames or borders, like they were embossed or something.
I also have a vague recollection that the company name was three letters like BFG or AMF or AMG or something like that.
I'm remembering it from like the 1970's maybe? Something in my lizard brain is telling me I saw it a lot in a bowling alley, but I could be completely wrong about that.
Edit: I can't find a logo for the AMF bowling company that matches my memory.