Kind of looking for a bit more information

I have a 4500 series ReplayTV and I will be "upgrading" to a DirectTivo in the next month. I like the replay and haven't had any major issues with it. If you are deciding between a standard Tivo and a Replay you might as well flip a coin. In my opinion the Tivo has a better interface and a little better software, the Replay has some nice extra features (commercial advance) and some gimmicks that most people never use (show sharing). The DirectTivo on the other hand is very slick (record two things at once, record the digital stream without recompression) and outshines anything replay currently has.

-Mike