Quote:
Doug, with all due respect, the Constitution exists to protect Americans, not foreigners who are captured in war.


So, this guy is not an American now? And since when were we at war with the UK?

And of course it seems a matter of debate about the control of the area exists. The US Government is trying to say that it is on foreign soil, thus the detainees there do not have rights they normally would have if held in an American prison.