In reply to:

Any tivo owners care to share a less one sided view?



Did I hear someone call for a TiVo zealot?

The most important capability of a PVR is the scheduling engine. Networking capabilities and other such features are gravy, IMO, and are only valuable if the thing records the programs you want it to record.

Replay's scheduling engine has been fundamentally flawed since day one. It's crazy complicated and simply doesn't do what you want it to. Version 5 of the Replay software looks like if finally gets rid of some of the more stupid things like the guaranteed recordings. But it still lags way behind TiVo.Here is a great comparison. Particularly pay attention to sections 13-16.

-Dylan