I interpreted his comments as going much further than the web site screw up. The incorrect spec is one thing, albeit a huge glaring cock up which is going to severely spoil somebody's day. However the rest of the post(s) was squarely a criticism of the Karma form factor. I tried to point out that being thicker than the iPod is only part of the story.

I've seen several other comments along the lines of "Oh, that's not big at all, I don't know what the fuss was about".

Rob