Quote:
tell me in your opinion which one is best and why.

Ah, another thread about religion.

First consideration is... if you already get your TV through DirecTV, then Tivo is your best option because they have the integrated unit where the satellite receiver is built into the box (actually, two of them are), and the stuff is saved to the hard disk directly without any A/D conversion or data compression.

If you have to get it as an add-on solution, then we're back to the religious discussion. Carry on...
_________________________
Tony Fabris