Seriously, when the droid army get personality, and why does it matter? The robot sarcastically saying 'You're welcome.' to Grevious? That and the Tarzan yell as the Wookies swing onto the amphibian droid. Why why why? Things like that serve only to deflate what little dramatic tension there was.

Padme was written too weakly. Her line about 'liberty ...(dying) to thunderous applause' would have been much better if she hadn't been so wishy washy, just going along with Anakin when he sides with the emporer.

Still, it was good eye candy and certainly didn't suck. Lucas has lost the touch & timing that brought us the 'Bad dates.' line in Indy.

-Zeke