TiVo, by default, will not record episodes that the guide data matches to another that was recorded in the last 28 days, but you can change it to "Record All Episodes."

I've never found the "Record First Run Only" to be reliable, because it uses the guide data to find the keywords "First Run" and I've seen guide data that said BOTH First Run and Repeat in it! What's up with that?

If you set the SP to be for Bravo only and do "First Run and Repeat" you should get all episodes that have not recorded in the last 28 days. Also change the number of eps to keep in case you want more than 5.