Originally Posted By: mlord
The Nest has a battery that renders the unit useless after 6-7 years. The $45 simpler ones last for decades.

CO detectors tend to have a lifespan of 2-7 years. Smoke detectors about 10. Replacement is advised after those times due to needing a newer sensor. Same applies for the Nest detector. It's not tied to battery life.

CO detector lifespan from two manufacturers:
http://www.kidde.com/customerservice/pages/replacecoalarmsevery7years.aspx
http://www.firstalert.com/faqs/co-alarm/...a-co-alarm-last

Smoke detector recommendation from fire marshals citing the 10 year recommendation:
https://www.firemarshals.org/rfsi/smokealarmfacts.html

10 years seems to have been picked based on historical failure rates. 3% fail in 10 years to detect properly. Out to 20 years and it jumps to 46% (Based on a Minnesota study, also referencing a study by the Ontario Canada Housing Corporation. https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/sfm/public-...replacement.pdf )